Wow, I ordered on Wednesday, it shipped Thursday and I got my box today!
The colors are Tart Deco, Turquoise and Caicos and Come Here! (they're all Essie and they're all still $8 on Essie's website). The other items are Essie Base Coat (says it's a special gift for June subscribers), Mash Tweezers, a little jar of gold studs and KM nail glue. This box was only $14.99 since they were offering your first month 1/2 off, so all in all I am pretty happy. I like the colors and I will definitely have fun coming up with a design with the studs.
I think I will get another month before deciding whether or not to cancel. The info sheet it came with says they want you to email them with your feedback and what colors I want to see next month. I appreciate that they care what people think