- View New Content
- Makeup and Beauty Forums
Makeup, Beauty & Fashion Talk
Subscriptions and Sampling Groups
Subscriptions and Sampling
- General Subscription & Sampling Programs
- Birchbox Subscribers
- Ipsy Subscribers
- Beauty Army
- Beauty Bar
- Glossybox Subscribers
- PopSugar Must Haves
- Quarterly Co.
- Le Metier De Beaute Beauty Vault VIP
- NewBeauty - Testube
- Fit Fab Fun VIP
- Fortune Cookie Soap
- Little Black Bag + Pose
- Consumer Testing Programs
- Subscriptions and Sampling
- Buy, Sell, Trade. Swap
- MUT Groups
- MUT Meetups
- Subscription Boxes
- Indie Rabbit Hole
Welcome Guest to MakeupTalk
Welcome to MakeupTalk, like most online communities you must register to view or post in our community, but don't worry this is a simple free process that requires minimal information for you to signup. Be apart of MakeupTalk by signing in or creating an account.
- Start new topics and reply to others in our MakeupTalk Forums
- Subscribe to topics and forums to get notification & email updates
- Get your personal profile page and make new friends in our Community
- Submit your reviews about Makeup Products and get feedback from other users
- Send personal messages to other members
Recent Images In This Topic/Thread
No Images in this topic
Best Brands for Eye Makeup?
66 replies to this topic
Posted 08 January 2006 - 07:02 AM
there seems to be alot of talk about MAC on this site. (im new) I've used mac, and like it well enough, but I was just wondering, are there any other brands of makeup (eyemakeup, i dont care about anythign else) that are as good or better than MAC? and also: can anyone recommend some eyeshadows that are sortof like, brown, but with a slight irredescence to them? I need both light brown and dark brown. I'm thinking of going out and trying some MAC pretty soon... unless there is something better. I like their mascara though :clap
Posted 08 January 2006 - 07:19 AM
First of all welcome to MUT!!!:icon_chee I prefer Stila than Mac!! I believe Stila has better quality of eyeshadows, they're more blendable, and Stila has the best natural shades! The brown shades I like from Stila are Golightly, it's a a dark chocolate brown with shimmers, Java it's a matte dark brown, and Summer a warm brown with some shimmers! But Stila has many browns like Espresso,Barefoot Contessa!
22 yrs old
Brown eyes and hair
LLL/ Mac NC20/ EDM Light/ Stila Shade C
Brown eyes and hair
LLL/ Mac NC20/ EDM Light/ Stila Shade C
Posted 08 January 2006 - 07:28 AM
Welcome here!!! I do love Mac, Stila, Bloom and Shu Uemura. To tell the truth, I heard a lot of good things about Kryolan, Kevyn Aucoin and Ben Nye (other professional make-up brands) too.
Posted 08 January 2006 - 07:54 AM
Shu and Stila!
Posted 08 January 2006 - 08:48 AM
Stila - high end - $16.00@ Milani - lower end - $3.49@
Live, Love, Laugh!
Posted 08 January 2006 - 09:43 AM
Stila and Shu also has great quality of e/s I like whole neutral shades from Stila. Shu uemura also has neutral iridescence, pear or metallic type of shades. I really like Shu's neutral brown and beige shades.
Posted 08 January 2006 - 11:12 AM
I think MAC is pretty great as far as quality, especially for the price... But the other makeup brands that I do like are - Milani - available in the US only, PM Greeneyedangel if you want a review, she lives in Canada as well, and I have CPd stuff for her before. Let me know if you need anything... - Stila - they have great e/s but their color selection isn't even close to MAC's - Prestige - available in CVS and Eckerds I think in the US and Canada, e/s, l/s, and l/g by them are really good Brown e/s recs - Milani Sheer Sand e/s, Milani Java Bean e/s, MAC Shroom e/s, MAC Woodwinked, MAC Tempting
I can see why the flamethrower was invented. There was someone who was sitting down thinking "I'm here, you're there, and I want to light you on fire..."
Posted 08 January 2006 - 01:02 PM
Agree...I'll also add Bobbi Brown and Nars to that list... I tried Kevin Aucoin's line at C.O. Bigelow (I didn't know they carried his line) very impressive... If you get a chance, go and test the lines and see how they look on you...
Posted 08 January 2006 - 01:38 PM
Oh, yes, I forgot about BB! I love that brand too. And guess... Nars isn't available in Italy, so I haven't tried anything from them :icon_evil
Posted 08 January 2006 - 01:46 PM
That sucks Mirtilla...I think it's a very nice line that gets overlooked sometimes...
Posted 08 January 2006 - 02:05 PM
I use so many different brands! And I love them all :icon_chee .
- Urban Decay make some amazing coloured eye shadows and they're really pigmented.
- Red Earth a bit hit and miss with their eye shadow, I have some that are really soft and pigmented and some that are a bit harder.
- Milani their eye shadows and "Luminous" blush are a staple part of my everyday makeup!
- Sweetscents over 300 shades of pigment eyeshadow, blusher and foundation. It's all made up just for you and the prices are great. I love their eye pigments.
- Pure Luxe more loose pigments but they do lipsticks and other face stuff, great for samples (they do samples of everything they carry and cost $1-2).
- The Body Shop the eye shadow Shimmercubes are wonderful! You get absolutely loads of product and they are all really pigmented and soft.
- Ben Nye very, very concentrated colour but the eye shadows are soft and easy to blend.
Posted 08 January 2006 - 03:13 PM
I love Guerlain, Mac, Chanel
Posted 08 January 2006 - 08:37 PM
This description perfectly describes Milani's Java Bean. Try it, at $3-4, what do you have to lose? Hi and welcome. I'm pretty new too. :icon_cool
Posted 11 January 2006 - 01:37 AM
okay i havnt heard of some of these dont know if theyre all in canada, or anywhere near me anyways but i will most certainly keep my eyes out thanks!
Posted 11 January 2006 - 01:49 AM
As far as high end, I would have to say the best quality to me that I have tried are Stila and Bobbi Brown. Stila has lots of shimmery shades, and matte, Bobbi Brown has mainly neutrals, but they are so soft, and they have some called Shimmer wash that have shimmer. BB is pretty expensive, but I get a lot of it on ebay cheap.
Posted 11 January 2006 - 12:39 PM
I have to say Stila. Although MAC have a fab colour range and the Veluxe Pearls are fab, i think the quality and texture of the Stila shadows is much nicer.
Posted 11 January 2006 - 06:12 PM
CoverGirl has a Good collectionof what i think you have in mind : CountryWoods. It is one of those eyeenhancers in 4 kits. It has "coffee(this one is Matte) Mink(this one is pearly), Barely Beiege (this one is matte), mocha (this one is pearly). Hope this helped!
Posted 11 January 2006 - 06:28 PM
i seem to be developing and attraction to victoria's secret - $11.00 and black opal - $4.00 drug store brand. colors work well for me and last all day.
Posted 11 January 2006 - 09:31 PM
I love many of brands listed above, but I'll throw in NYX shadows. They have a great color selection and some pretty shimmery shades. It's one of the best for funky colors in the drugstore price-range. :icon_love
Posted 11 January 2006 - 10:32 PM
Loreal- Nice shades and they are long lasting. They have shimmering shades as well. Almay- they have new eye shadows out. Pretty good.