Ahh, ditto on the finally a pale highlighter thing! I really liked the formula for the lipglosses a lot and absolutely loved the blush - I like cream blush to begin with, and thought this formula was great. Also thought the eyeliner was great (although, yeah, don't really need black eyeliner at this point) and can always use brow gel. Haven't tried the eyeshadows yet.
I have a super-close family friend who is quite wealthy, obsessed with buying makeup, and her two daughters are total hippies, so she saves it all up and gives it to me when I visit. She is super pale, i'm only regular pale, so the stuff that is too dark for her I usually wind up getting. She gave me a ton of mally stuff last time I saw her and i liked everything except for a concealer that was too light for me. I actually bought a refill of it in the correct color from Ulta because you can just pop it into the compact. Overall I've been surprised with how much I like the line.