[Ashley]

I can't help you with specific shades because you're a bit darker than me, but I did notice this when I got tons of samples with my pre-buy brushes: I've noticed that the same shade varies so much depending on the formula. From all my samples, it seems like Flawless significantly lighter, VV and cashmere are in the middle, and pretty close to each other, and luminesse is significantly darker.

My two favorites were probably flawless and luminesse. Flawless doesn't really give a glow, it just seems like a good medium coverage foundation. Luminesse gives a glow like BE. I felt so-so on VV and Cashmere.