[peachface]

Originally Posted by Gavriela

I haven't had any problems with CG's Volume Exact smearing, smudging, or creating little lines under my eyes, and been using that for a while - non-waterproof variety.

Thanks! I'm going to give it a try!

Originally Posted by xtiffanyx

Loreal's Double Extend waterproof mascara stays put all day when I use it. It takes me forever to take it off at night. A lot of waterproof mascaras I've used smudge a little throughout the day, but this one never has.

What do you use to take it off? Is it hard to take off even with a makeup remover?

Originally Posted by reesesilverstar

I have the waterproof maybelline XXL volume and length... It doesn't budge on me...

Thanks for the info. I can't remember if I've tried it or not. Is it the one that comes with a primer?

Originally Posted by Killah Kitty

I find using a primer before mascara helps it stay put a lot better. As for something that lasts through tears, sweat, everything, hmm I think I had the best luck with Maybelline Great Lash actually lol, not even waterproof. Chanel Inimitable is holding up just as well, but is at the other end of the price range.

Yeah... maybe I should consider a primer... I've tried Maybelline Great Lash but I don't know why people love it so much. I never liked it but then I can't remember if it smudged or not. I haven't tried Chanel but yeah, it's probably out of my price range!! Thanks!