Found it!!! I called so many different pharmacies and finally one told me that there were just putting it on display today. Why put it in the ad for sale in our area and then not even have it?
I got Classic Beige and True Beige knowing I would be returning one. My judgement was correct in that True Beige is too dark and orange for me, (they had testers for most of them) but I had to make sure. I'd much rather return an item knowing it didn't work then not buy, regret it, go get it and possibly return it. Classic Beige tested on my jaw looks beautifly creamy matte and soft and IT MATCHES PERFECTLY so far... But I will test this out for the next few days since were having horrible heat and humidity, perfect conditions to see what this stuff is made of.
My Colorstay could withstand the heat and humidity pretty well but I hate hate hate having to mix mine and I'm having a hard time getting past the smell. It makes me nauseous and gives me a headache. It's ironic bc it didn't do that the first time I tried it and I actually loved the smell at the time but now, using it second time around, I can't stand it.
Oops! Also wanted to add that I think this may be replacing the old Superstay Silky formula. All the ones on the rack were 50% off so if someone uses it, go to CVS for half off before they're gone

.