[summerxdreams]

I've been looking around and it seems that these two mascaras are pretty much the same with the rubber brushes - does anyone have any recommendations on which to get?

And also, for waterproof formulas - do they clump more and are they any different from the normal formulas (except for the fact that they're waterproof LOL)

[cheesecake]

Although I've never tried Lash Exact, I highly recommend Lash Perfection WP. LP WP has replaced Loreal's Voluminous WP as my fav. LP's brush is wonderful in that I can reach those hard to reach lashes and I NEVER get clumps even when I use many coats. LP holds a fabulous curl as well as giving me volume and length. I'm very impressed!

[Lindabear]

i tried both, i like lash exact more, it isn't clumpii :] and it doesn't get all smudgie by the end of school. so far best mascara ive ever tried. i haven't tried waterproof,.

[Marisol]

I like both.

[eowyn797]

i use Lash Exact religiously. i didn't see a difference between it and Perfection, so i'm stickin' with my Exact

[Delphine]

I only tried lash perfection and I liked it. I can't really compare though...

[vickih]

lash perfection

[summerxdreams]

Thanks everyone Anyone else have an opinion on the comparison?

[emily]

I haven't used lash perfection but I've heard some good things--I have tried lash exact and really like it--but they've come out with a new rubber-brush mascara called Volume Exact that I like even more! Goes on just as well without clumping but somehow deposits more formula on your lashes and really plumps them up! I'd recommend trying it!

[meomunngoc]

Lash Extract

[PinkOcho]

Ive used both, and i loved lash perfection much more!!

[dalvia]

L'Oreal-Double Extension Waterproof Mascara
and
Estee Lauder- Lash XL Maximum Length Mascara
are both very good...

[Aquilah]

I've only tried CG Lash Exact, so I can't compare them to each other... I do know Rimmel now has a mascara like these too...

[perlanga]

Haven't tried Lash Exact, but the Lp brush and formula is pretty good.

[Mari168]

I have tried both an in my opinion there is no comparison. I have sparse, short, very wimpy lashes and the Max Factor Lash Perfection is the one for me. I have to build it up since I don't have much to work with but I feel that it is more volume building and more curling. My mother even compliments me when I use it.

Marilyn

[Leony]

I've tried them.
If you want to look more natural, try Lash Exact.
If you want to look more bold looking, get Lash Perfection.

I personally like both.