[Aquilah]

Disclaimer ~ I don't think there's another thread similar to this... Sorry if so...

Okay, supposing MAC decided as of tomorrow they're only making three pigments and three e/s... ONLY THREE OF EACH!!! They're calling on their loyal MAC lovers to tell them which three of each... They can be from the regular line, any LE or even discontinued colors. ONLY THREE THOUGH!!!

***I know this would NEVER happen, but it's probably going to challenge a lot of you... And I think this would be pretty fun! Oh yeah, and I can't even answer my own question because I haven't tried any of the e/s, and I think there's some pigments I'd LOVE to have over a few sample ones I do have***

[Thais]

I only have 3 of their eyeshadows so I probably can't help you there... LOL

As for pigments, I think I would go for: Goldenaire, Tan, chocolate brown.

[Marisol]

Eye Shadows-
Vapour
Trax
Soft Brown

Pigments -
Kelly Green
Deckchair
Coco

[semantje]

dont know about the shadows. but about the pigments:

lily white
violet
Chartreuse

[KellyB]

e/s
Nocturnelle
Contrast
Antiqued

Piggies
Blue/Brown
Choc Brown
Cornflower

[chocobon]

Don't know about piggies but shadows :
Woodwinked
Black tied
Embark

[jennycateyez]

e/s- humid, naked lunch, amber lights

pigments- not to crazy about any of them lol

[Amandine]

Pigments:
Blue Brown
Coco
Rose

Eyeshadow:
Amber Lights
Parrot
Say Yeah!

[erica_1020]

Shadows-Amberlights, Swimming, Expensive Pink (sold this and rebought)

I don't use pigments I am too much of a clutz

[mac-whore]

Pigments: Frost, Tan, Gold Lemon

Eyeshadows: Botanical, Shroom, Black Tied

[pinkbundles]

e/s: black tied, satin taupe, expensive pink

pigments? can't help you there, haven't tried them...though i did nab a full size goldenaire at my counter last week!

[jaydensmom]

My 3 favorite MAC eye shadows:
-Nylon
-Sumptuous Olive
-Woodwinked

Haven't really experimented with the pigments. I am too clumsy

[AudreyNicole]

Yikes, that's a tough one!

Eyeshadows:
* Expensive Pink
* Steamy
* Coppering

Pigments:
* Vanilla
* Kitchmas
* Pink Opal

[foxyqt]

eyeshadows: trax, shimmermoss & bronze =)

dunno about the piggies but Blue Brown wud be one of'em!

[Quiana]

E/S: Humid, Beauty Marked, Steamy
Piggies: Dont have any that really stand out..but I plan on loading up on pro piggies when I go to Orlando in a month
P.S. You guys have got me wanting to check out this Expensive Pink.....