[Anna]

ok. so i found my kitten and i compared. they arent an EXACT match for each other kitten is more pink. BUT they are very similar so if you want the look of kitten but not the price milani is a nice alternative. the texture of the milani is rough IMO, but the color is still nice. my blue tooth has decided it doesnt want to work right now so as soon as it feels like working ill upload my comparasin pics. and they do blend nicely together. i blended them together and put rose gold pigment in the crease ad its pretty! but again when bluetooth wants to work ill have pics

[Aquilah]

Well, I reckon I have to wait for the Bluetooth to wanna work for pics

[Jennifer]

whether identical or not, i still love stila's e/s all the way! nothing compares. thanks for the info!

[CuTeLiCiOuS]

Thankyou I am always looking for a bargin or a cheaper priced product. I need to get "department store better than drugstore" out of my head. Aggh so much condtioning lol.

[Kathy]

I've never used any Stila shadows yet, but I do like Milani. Thannks for the post, Video Queen! lol...off topic, how are they?

[Leony]

Thanks for the info. I also found one of Japanese e/s brand a bit similar with Stila Kitten.

Originally Posted by Jennifer

whether identical or not, i still love stila's e/s all the way! nothing compares. thanks for the info!

Ditto.

[mandy_]

I have both. I would choose the Stila one over the Milani one any day because I like the texture better. I do looove the color of the Milani one though!

[Thais]

Thank you for the heads up!

[Anna]

Originally Posted by mandy_

I have both. I would choose the Stila one over the Milani one any day because I like the texture better. I do looove the color of the Milani one though!

me too the texture is WAY better in stila. but it is a nice alternative and it was like a passifier while i lost my kitten

[StereoXGirl]

You lost your Kitten? That sucks!

I just checked my stash and, you're right, the colors are similar! The Stila goes on much smoother and has more shimmer/frost on my lids, though. I still use both shadows! lol.

[Cool Kitten]

i hate, hate, hate Sheer Sand. It's gritty, un-pigmented, and there's no color pay-off. I ended up scraping the e/s out and using the pan for pressing pigments.
Stila is frosty, but the texture is great, it's pigmented and the color pay-off is amazing.

[emily_3383]

i dont think its the same and as Cool Kitten said its really gritty!