[Marisol]

Most of my lippies are MAC and they are lustres.

[FeistyFemme]

I prefer a glossy finish.

[x3kh]

Glossy!

[321maami]

first preference is color.

[MrsLT]

I love creamy lipsticks

[Noir Sakura]

Brown or plum in color with a glossy finish.

[Sarah84]

glossy for me which is why i dont really always wear lipstick much more of a lipgloss fan

[blonde65]

I like both, sorry can't choose. lol

[Turquoise917]

I have a soft spot for lipstick since my very first piece of make-up was Clinique Long Last Soft Shine in Creamy Nude I don't like it too matte or too glossy. I use lip gloss for that. Sometimes I try mixing different colors whether it's a lipstick or gloss. I like neutral pink shades for everyday.

[AngelaGM]

I have different preferences depending on the lipstick.

[hollywoo]

Creamy+1
Glossy+1

[alliestella]

I prefer them to be glossy.

[Jennifer]

i love creamy ones, but depends which look i'm going after. i have all.

[SimplyElegant]

Creamy but sheer too. I look like a clown if it's too pigmented.

[Gail Evans]

creamy, and slightly darker than normal lip-colour; that's about all.
I sometimes put gloss over the top, but mostly lipbalm underneath before 'sticking.

[CoverGirl]

I love nude colors, especially with a frost finish.