I tried both and I think they are similar. Aubrey Nicole doesn't have enough color shades, I couldn't find a match with them. I tried full coverage and it wasn't enough coverage for my blemishes (Lumiere Veena Velvet covered them without much layering). Meow Pampered Puss has very light coverage (almost sheer on me), I had to put on 4 layers just to even out my skin tone (I'm losing my tan in some areas of my face), plus my blemishes were still visible. I am going to try it again without buffing it on my face.
I LOVE Meow's Premiere Puss Primer.

It has kept my T-zone oil-free for hours. This is the first product that controls my oil because normally I have to blot my face every hour (super oily due to using cleanser/moisterisers that dry out my skin). I wish they sold a 3oz jar of it! The Top Cat finishing powder is also nice.
Both companies gave generous samples & freebies. I got a free Feliner & blush from Meow and Aubrey Nicole sent me 2 free blushes. Aubrey Nicole gives the largest samples I've seen, my 5g sifters were overflowing with minerals! Meow's sample baggies were almost 20% full.
Meow Naughty Abysinnian has a subtle shimmer to it. I didn't notice it in the bag but I can see it on my face. It doesn't look bad, I love shimmer but I can't fake natural skin with it on. I am going to check if the shimmer is in the other colors.
I think you should try samples from both companies and see which one suits you the best.