[rossana]

Originally Posted by bela

carbon black doesnt flake or get too dry as long as you replace it before it gets all old.i am also a big fan of very black mascaras and i love carbon black.not to mention it would be alot cheaper and easier to get since you live so far from sephora

Hi!
that's my first time here, and I agree!

[sweet67]

I use DiorShow mascara. It's extremely black. I think it would be the perfect choice for you. I myself like really dark mascara.

[rossana]

It's very difficult to remove!I use a normal remover, but it's not enough! What do you use to remove it?

[Killah Kitty]

I think next time I get to go to Sephora I am going to pick between Diorshow or Bourjous, I cant afford both lol. So far Im still loving my Carbon Voluminous.

I use Neautrogena Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover. It does a perfect job of removing any mascara Ive tried, even waterproof ones, just let it soak on your eye with a cotton pad for a few seconds.

The only one I had trouble with was Lancome mascaras, I really dislike those, they don't do anything for me and they don't like being removed either.

[rossana]

Here in Bolzano (Italy) there's not "Bourjors", but I kwow it.
I remembered that 4 years ago they had a wonderful black mascara!
You're lucky, I want it too!
I bought a Rimmel mascara, because a was couriose....it's awful!!!!
I would like to try Dior mascara or Chanel...
What would you chose?

[~Ms.August~365]

MAC pro lash in COAL BLACK is blacker than your blackest black LOL

[GraceEvan]

Lancome L'Extreme Mascara is good. It's difficult to remove if mascara is tooo black...

[fashion_junkie]

Diorshow Blackout is super dark.

[rossana]

thanks to everyone!now I go
I need it, today was a bad day!

[Adrienne]

Revlon's 3d mascara is really black but unless you know how to wield the wand, it does you no good.

[Killah Kitty]

MAC coal black sounds nice lol, I liked MAC Plush lash when I tried it but the wand was just too weird... maybe the coal black is as dark as the plush lash but with a more normal brush...

[badbadgirl]

Originally Posted by Killah Kitty

I think next time I get to go to Sephora I am going to pick between Diorshow or Bourjous, I cant afford both lol. So far Im still loving my Carbon Voluminous.

I use Neautrogena Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover. It does a perfect job of removing any mascara Ive tried, even waterproof ones, just let it soak on your eye with a cotton pad for a few seconds.

The only one I had trouble with was Lancome mascaras, I really dislike those, they don't do anything for me and they don't like being removed either.

The Bourjois in Absolute Black (I think that's how it is described) will be darker than Diorshow.

[moccah]

I freaking hate diorshow, it might be really black but for some reason it sucks on me...maybe im not applying it right? (is there a special way to apply diorshow?)
And Ive never like bourjois mascara since they clump always.

I do like the revlon 3d mascara, but as already told, the wand needs a special hand to get it nice, but when you get to use to the wand, its great
Best ever is still l'oreal double extend beauty tubes, perfect volume, curl and black black black

[evening_star]

Originally Posted by Faith-Abigail

Dior's Diorshow Blackout is very black, as well. There's something in the formula...resin maybe?...that's really black and has reflective properties for a dark, wet look.

Diorshow Blackout all the way!!!

[Faith-Abigail]

Originally Posted by moccah

I freaking hate diorshow, it might be really black but for some reason it sucks on me...maybe im not applying it right? (is there a special way to apply diorshow?)

You just have to work with it. I find if I keep wiggling the wand over my lashes, the application looks really lush and clump-free. It also helps if you use a mascara base.

[perlanga]

I've tried the great lash blackest black and it's dark, but he formula sucks. I prefer WnW Megaplump in carbon black, it is so rich.