I bought this mascara in extremely black. It is extremely black, but I wouldnt say its anything show stopping, just very very nice lol. I liked this mascara, its smooth and makes my lashes look very long and well seperated. I use it on top of a primer, so it lasted comfortably all day for me, no flakes or smudges! It didnt add much volume, more enhanced my already numerous long curly lashes, didn't perform any miracles, but I still like it, great color, consistency, and brush! Id buy it again!

I only gave it 3 stars because although it was initally an awesome mascara, it was starting to get clumpy and dry within 3 weeks. It became hard to apply and the brush is good, but the small outer edge of it has no bristles, so its very difficult to get to little lashes, or to seperate a clump.

Well, so far so good! I love the brush - kinda like Maybelline's Define-a-lash brush, but not as bendy.

 

Good separation, volume. I bought it in Extremely Black and it really lives up to it's name. No clumping or flaking so far.

 

I recommend this mascara, and would definitely repurchase it.

i thought this mascara was horrible.  It clumps, flakes, and somehow even STRAIGHTENs your lashes out instead of keeping the curl...

As a mascara addict, when i saw it i had to try it when i saw that they have one of the new brushes.  As usual, i wish it was waterproof, but although it is not as black as HIP, it does open and lift more than most non waterproof do, and i like this brush more than the one for covergirl outlast.