Love this stuff - gave it a 4 because of the packaging...if they could manage to get it into a tube, I'd be set. I know that the smell takes getting used to (it's pleasant but I can see how others might not find it so) but using it long term really makes a difference.

 

It isn't just vaseline with smell; the results I get are better with this. This is also better than my previous HG Kiehl's Lip Balm. I used to love Kiehls but Rosebud is somehow better, it's also less sticky. That said, it does warrant reapplication because of this.

 

Reapplication doesn't bother me given the result- I had HUGE problems with chapped lips before I found this stuff. So bad my lips would crack and bleed. And it was ALL the time - winter, summer. I don't know where it came from. Nothing helped - not Kiehls, not vaseline, not even doctor prescribed hydracortisone. Until I started with this stuff. Now my lips have returned to their previous soft selves and I'm never looking back!