I called and spoke to a manager at our Ulta this morning. She was properly appalled at the situation and said that all NYX lipglosses and eye liners would be pulled and thrown away immediately. She also said that there will be a person assigned to "patrol" that area of the store because she said that it has been a huge problem since they opened. She said that they have had several complaints about the NYX section. I don't know if she was just placating me, but at least it's something. I also sent off and email to NYX this morning explaining that until they put some sort of tamper proof packaging/stickers/plastic on their products, I will not be purchasing them and I would be advising others to do the same. I understand that people will still open packaging, but if something is in place, at least others will be able to tell that it's been used and not unknowingly purchase a product that has touched someone's face. Their customers safety should really be more important to them. Hopefully, they won't just brush me off.
Actually NYX products are sealed with a plastic wrap BUT it's easy to remove the top without disturbing the plastic wrap. Not everything is wrapped though so I now try to check to make sure the product I'm buying is new and not used.