Which box was your original one and which one are you getting now?
Featured Stories
Topics Discussed
Popular Group Discussions
-
Birchbox (Woman) May 2013 2224 posts | Last post on Yesterday at 9:06 pm
Related Forum Threads
- How To: Add trade link to your signature Last post on 5/1/13 at 11:53am in [How do I?] - User Profiles
- (SPOILERS) Birchbox: December 2012 boxes Last post on 12/21/12 at 3:43am in Birchbox Subscribers
- Glossybox December 2012 Last post on 2/16/13 at 6:58am in Subscription & Sampling Programs
- Sumita Color Contrast Eyeliner Last post on 12/9/12 at 9:47pm in Makeup Talk
- twistband™ Hair Tie Last post on 11/12/12 at 9:37pm in Hair Care Talk
Related Articles
-
Join a Popular Subscriptions and Sampling Group!
Edited on 5/4/13
- MakeupTalk Holiday Buying Guide (Subscription & Sample Programs)
Edited on 11/6/12Related Makeup & More
Recent Reviews
-
OUTRAGEOUSLY AWESOME!! I can not say enough about this hair color. I had an epic disaster with Wild Ombre by Loreal. It turned my dark brown...
-
WORST. INVENTION. EVER. I purchased the Wild Ombre kit at a CVS this past Tuesday after deciding I wanted to try the trend out and change it up a little. Boy oh boy was I wrong. First...
-
I received this as a gift from Sephora and I wanted to use it as a lip balm that could give me a sheer wash of color, and could apply easily without a mirror. Because of my job, I have to keep my...
-
Ipsy has made its way as a fierce competitor in subscription services. They have, for the most part, worked out their growing pain issues from early 2012. There are very few shipping or broken item...
-
This is my go-to product for under eye circles. It's fabulous and a little goes a long way!
- MakeupTalk Holiday Buying Guide (Subscription & Sample Programs)
Birchbox Subscribers
Birchbox: December 2012 - Page 67
Beauty Gear mentioned in this thread:
Box 11 with
- Benefit it's potent! eye cream
- Chuao Chocolatier Assorted ChocoPod
- Kérastase Resistance Ciment Thermique - Protect
- ModelCo SHINE Ultra Lip Gloss
Now I'm getting the one with the lipgloss, CC cream, hand sanitizer wipes, shampoo and Nicole Richie perfume.
I mean, its not a terrible box, I'm not just excited for the perfume, shampoo or hand sanitizer,
- Kyuu
- Trader Feedback: +3
- /人◕‿‿◕人\
-
- offline
- 1,054 Posts. Joined 8/2012
- Location: New York City
- Select All Posts By This User
- Scooby384
- Trader Feedback: +47
-
- offline
- 1,778 Posts. Joined 1/2012
- Location: Austin TX
- Select All Posts By This User
Example: if you have 300 points and your order total comes to $21, it will use all 300 points. If your order total comes to $19, it will use 200.
- BrittneyMarie
- Trader Feedback: +6
- Indifferent Peapod
-
- offline
- 410 Posts. Joined 2/2012
- Location: Ohio
- Select All Posts By This User
Doesn't work that way :(

Not cool, BB. I got my email on the 10th that you shipped my box, and now I get a follow up that my box has not shipped but is delayed because of "inventory issues." Now, as you're not planning to ship my box until a full week from today, I guess I'll be lucky if it shows up before the new year. I mean, a 100 points is great and all, but really? *sigh*
Anyone else in the same boat as me?
Me too. Works out well since I didn't have enough points for anything, and now I have a free $10 to spend. I'm canceling this month anyway, so it's not a big deal to me, but it would have been annoying if I wanted to put any of that stuff in as stocking stuffers!
- BabyMafalda
- Trader Feedback: +2
-
- offline
- 169 Posts. Joined 2/2012
- Location: Georgia
- Select All Posts By This User
- quene8106
- Trader Feedback: +7
- ᏣᎳᎩ ᎠᏂᏴᏫᏯᎢ
-
- offline
- 1,236 Posts. Joined 3/2012
- Location: VA
- Select All Posts By This User

Box 11 with
- Benefit it's potent! eye cream
- Chuao Chocolatier Assorted ChocoPod
- Kérastase Resistance Ciment Thermique - Protect
- ModelCo SHINE Ultra Lip Gloss
Now I'm getting the one with the lipgloss, CC cream, hand sanitizer wipes, shampoo and Nicole Richie perfume.
I mean, its not a terrible box, I'm not just excited for the perfume, shampoo or hand sanitizer,
oh ok. the box that you're getting now is the one i got (box 16). it's not bad but it's not awesome. box 11 sounded really good, even if you only had 4 items in it. i hate when bb switches up boxes on people at the last minute =/
- queenofperil
- Trader Feedback: +1
-
- offline
- 458 Posts. Joined 10/2012
- Location: SoCal
- Select All Posts By This User
My box page finally updated. December's Birchbox should be here on the 20th, so it's like an early Xmas gift. I'm getting box 2. It's not my dream box, but I'm excited to try almost every product in there. It has:
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
ModelCo SHINE Ultra Lip Gloss (The only thing I'm kinda 'eh' about and would trade)
Another awesome part is that everything in this box appears to be a really good size. I love Birchbox, but this month I feel that same excitement I had when I first joined.
- msdollfaced
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- online
- 213 Posts. Joined 9/2012
- Location: IL
- Select All Posts By This User
Has anyone ever received a different box than what was listed on your profile?? When I log in and check my box it lists me as getting: mary-lou manizer, fortune cookie, kerastase, nicole by nicole richie and the juice beauty cc cream but the box that I received today in the mail contains: frownies eye gels, fortune cookie, rent the runway coupon, j.r watkins salve, hot mama blush and nick chavez shampoo
I was looking forward to the mary-lou and now my box is almost unusable. I'm a size 24 so the rent the runway thing is out and I never have worn blush. But, on the other hand I am really glad that I didn't receive the cc cream or the perfume so I guess this is a plus for me.
Has anyone else had this happen? Is this worth notifying BB about or is it a bit trivial?
Edited by msdollfaced - 12/15/12 at 2:16pm

Has anyone ever received a different box than what was listed on your profile?? When I log in and check my box it lists me as getting: mary-lou manizer, fortune cookie, kerastase, nicole by nicole richie and the juice beauty cc cream but the box that I received today in the mail contains: frownies eye gels, fortune cookie, rent the runway coupon, j.r watkins salve, hot mama blush and nick chavez shampoo
I was looking forward to the mary-lou and now my box is almost unusable. I'm a size 24 so the rent the runway thing is out and I never have worn blush. But, on the other hand I am really glad that I didn't receive the cc cream or the perfume so I guess this is a plus for me.
Has anyone else had this happen? Is this worth notifying BB about or is it a bit trivial?
I would contact them, so you can have the opportunity to be able to review the correct items and get your points!
- quene8106
- Trader Feedback: +7
- ᏣᎳᎩ ᎠᏂᏴᏫᏯᎢ
-
- offline
- 1,236 Posts. Joined 3/2012
- Location: VA
- Select All Posts By This User

Has anyone ever received a different box than what was listed on your profile?? When I log in and check my box it lists me as getting: mary-lou manizer, fortune cookie, kerastase, nicole by nicole richie and the juice beauty cc cream but the box that I received today in the mail contains: frownies eye gels, fortune cookie, rent the runway coupon, j.r watkins salve, hot mama blush and nick chavez shampoo
I was looking forward to the mary-lou and now my box is almost unusable. I'm a size 24 so the rent the runway thing is out and I never have worn blush. But, on the other hand I am really glad that I didn't receive the cc cream or the perfume so I guess this is a plus for me.
Has anyone else had this happen? Is this worth notifying BB about or is it a bit trivial?
yup. i told them and they gave me 100 points

Has anyone ever received a different box than what was listed on your profile?? When I log in and check my box it lists me as getting: mary-lou manizer, fortune cookie, kerastase, nicole by nicole richie and the juice beauty cc cream but the box that I received today in the mail contains: frownies eye gels, fortune cookie, rent the runway coupon, j.r watkins salve, hot mama blush and nick chavez shampoo
I was looking forward to the mary-lou and now my box is almost unusable. I'm a size 24 so the rent the runway thing is out and I never have worn blush. But, on the other hand I am really glad that I didn't receive the cc cream or the perfume so I guess this is a plus for me.
Has anyone else had this happen? Is this worth notifying BB about or is it a bit trivial?
Let them know, because I don't think you can submit feedback and get points for the items you received...
- queenofperil
- Trader Feedback: +1
-
- offline
- 458 Posts. Joined 10/2012
- Location: SoCal
- Select All Posts By This User
- zadidoll
- Trader Feedback: +10
- PM me or email me if you have any questions about Makeup Talk. Make sure to read MUT's Terms of Service.for details on what's allowed on MUT.
-
- offline
- 10,978 Posts. Joined 2/2011
- Location: USA
- Select All Posts By This User
- lovestarbrooke
- Trader Feedback: +1
-
- offline
- 146 Posts. Joined 2/2012
- Location: Upstate New York
- Select All Posts By This User

My box page finally updated. December's Birchbox should be here on the 20th, so it's like an early Xmas gift. I'm getting box 2. It's not my dream box, but I'm excited to try almost every product in there. It has:
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
(The only thing I'm kinda 'eh' about and would trade)
12 Benefits™ Instant Healthy Hair Treatment
(Super excited to try this)
NUXE Masque Crème Fraîche de Beauté (Been wanting to try NUXE forever, and I need a travel size face mask for vacation next month. Win win)
Emily's Chocolates Chocolate Covered Fortune Cookies (Everything about this sounds good)
Fresh Citron de Vigne Rollerball
(My aunt has this and I LOVE it)
This was my dream box!
- lovestarbrooke
- Trader Feedback: +1
-
- offline
- 146 Posts. Joined 2/2012
- Location: Upstate New York
- Select All Posts By This User

Has anyone ever received a different box than what was listed on your profile?? When I log in and check my box it lists me as getting: mary-lou manizer, fortune cookie, kerastase, nicole by nicole richie and the juice beauty cc cream but the box that I received today in the mail contains: frownies eye gels, fortune cookie, rent the runway coupon, j.r watkins salve, hot mama blush and nick chavez shampoo
I was looking forward to the mary-lou and now my box is almost unusable. I'm a size 24 so the rent the runway thing is out and I never have worn blush. But, on the other hand I am really glad that I didn't receive the cc cream or the perfume so I guess this is a plus for me.
Has anyone else had this happen? Is this worth notifying BB about or is it a bit trivial?
- Kyuu
- Trader Feedback: +3
- /人◕‿‿◕人\
-
- offline
- 1,054 Posts. Joined 8/2012
- Location: New York City
- Select All Posts By This User
I'm not sure how happy I am with birchbox. On one hand, I'm not loving everything I got (GRRRR NICOLE RICHIE PERFUME). I found maybe like 1 or 2 things TOTAL out of the stuff they sent me that I love and would want to rebuy... on the other hand, I've gotten nice samples of other stuff I find useful that's large enough to last a while and maybe wouldn't have wanted to buy myself. I already have a lot of HGs but it's nice to be able to try something just for the sake of it.
I did a little bit of thinking. Technically, Birchbox has a really nice shop. It's not as well stocked as Sephora's, but there are definitely a lot of prestige brands in there, and stuff that a lot of places wouldn't discount regularly (Sephora and Ulta), whereas you're guaranteed that 20% off every ___ months. I guess it's a cost-benefit thing.
Technically, you get ~50 points for every box you get, or about $5 back from each box. If you buy a yearly subscription, that's 110 points + 50*12, or ~$70 (well, $71 but it doesn't translate like that), and that's not including any accidentals (where you get another $5-10 in points usually). If you catch it at another time when they do the buy ___ of stuff get double points thing, you get back even more (like another $10) Let's face it, most of us are going to drop that ~$70 cosmetics in 3-4 months if not even more frequently, much less a year, and through their shop, you get the added bonus of 20% off, and likely another sample from you pick two.
That means you are technically paying only ~$40 for 12 months of samples, which comes down to $3.33 box, since the rest is given back to you. Love it or hate it, it's not that much money for 5 things, some of which have been and could be awesome. In other words, for example, if you bought a pack with a $10 coupon and one item (worth, say $30) for $15, you technically only paid $5 for this $30 item, since the $10 gift card can be treated "like" cash. So in this case, you're paying $3.33 for a box of 5 items, because the other amount is coming back to you.
As frustrated as I am with BB sometimes, I think I'll stick with them. I'm not sure how I feel about Sephora's rewards system, but I definitely think Birchbox has a better rewards system than they do. If you think Birchbox less as a sampling service and more as a beauty store in which you first invest money into and slowly get the stuff back from, it is worth it.
Got box 13 and really like it! However, I was totally expecting a decent size Ahava Foot Cream since that's what they show in the picture. Instead, I got one single use packet. Boo.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
- kawaiimeows
- Trader Feedback: 0
- (=`ω´=)
-
- offline
- 1,601 Posts. Joined 4/2012
- Select All Posts By This User

Got box 13 and really like it! However, I was totally expecting a decent size Ahava Foot Cream since that's what they show in the picture. Instead, I got one single use packet. Boo.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
This is my box too. The fact that the foot cream is a single use packet coupled with the TWO perfume samples being forced on me makes for a really disappointing box this month for me. But it is hard to top last months since I got full sized mascara.

Got box 13 and really like it! However, I was totally expecting a decent size Ahava Foot Cream since that's what they show in the picture. Instead, I got one single use packet. Boo.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
That's the same box I got (twice!). I was also a little disappointed in the foot cream size. Was the cap on your lip butter? My first box was on, but loose, but the one that came today was completely off and the balm was all gouged out because it got on some of the other products.
- zadidoll
- Trader Feedback: +10
- PM me or email me if you have any questions about Makeup Talk. Make sure to read MUT's Terms of Service.for details on what's allowed on MUT.
-
- offline
- 10,978 Posts. Joined 2/2011
- Location: USA
- Select All Posts By This User


Got box 13 and really like it! However, I was totally expecting a decent size Ahava Foot Cream since that's what they show in the picture. Instead, I got one single use packet. Boo.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
That's the same box I got (twice!). I was also a little disappointed in the foot cream size. Was the cap on your lip butter? My first box was on, but loose, but the one that came today was completely off and the balm was all gouged out because it got on some of the other products.
Wait they sent a FOIL packed instead of the 1 oz tube? I have the full size from AHAVA and a 1 oz tube from BB from months ago and it's okay I really don't care for their Water line but do like their Mud line instead.
That's exactly what it is, Zadi!
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
sorry for the terrible lighting.
- zadidoll
- Trader Feedback: +10
- PM me or email me if you have any questions about Makeup Talk. Make sure to read MUT's Terms of Service.for details on what's allowed on MUT.
-
- offline
- 10,978 Posts. Joined 2/2011
- Location: USA
- Select All Posts By This User
- Birchbox: December 2012
Recent Discussions
- › Julep May 2013 4 minutes ago
- › Glamour Doll Eyes OTM: May 2013 24 minutes ago
- › Gwynnie Bee (Plus size clothes rental) 38 minutes ago
- › Like it, love it, hate it, never tried it -food 54 minutes ago
- › calling all makeup addicts! 59 minutes ago
- › May 2013 Ipsy bag!!! (Spoilers) 1 hour ago
- › Chain Reaction 1 hour, 30 minutes ago
- › 4 Letter Word Game 1 hour, 31 minutes ago
- › Word Association Game! 1 hour, 52 minutes ago
- › More neutral palettes than one person could ever need... 2 hours, 21 minutes ago
Recent Reviews
- › Garnier Olia Oil Powered Permanent Haircolor, 6.3 Light Golden Brown by Cosmobella20
- › L'Oreal Feria Wild Ombre Hair Color, O60 Medium to Dark Brown by Cosmobella20
- › Fresh Sugar Rose Tinted Lip Treatment SPF 15 Sugar Plum Tinted Lip... by laguilar12
- › Ipsy... beauty by you by tgooberbutt
- › Benefit Erase Paste by onecheekychica
- › Benefit Boi-ing by onecheekychica
- › Be A Bombshell Blush - Sweet Cheeks by jessilng
- › L'Oreal Sublime Bronze by jessilng
- › Benefit Cosmetics hello flawless oxygen wow! - IVORY by Hokipoki1213
- › Lime Crime VELVETINES - SUEDEBERRY by Bria
New Articles
- › The Lip Bar Contest by alyssaw
- › 3 Ways to Get a New Spring Look for Under $6 by thewendyyybird
- › The Truth About Tanning Beds by Director
- › Cream vs. Powered Eyeshadows by Director
- › How to Get a Fresh, Bright-Eyed Look by thewendyyybird
- › Join a Popular Subscriptions and Sampling Group! by Director
- › All About Hair Oil by thewendyyybird
- › The Dark Side of Trade Shows by zadidoll
- › 4 Nail Polish Collections for Summer 2013 by Dalylah
- › Buying Guide: 4 Neutral Eye Shadow Palettes... by Dalylah
About MakeupTalk.com | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 MakeupTalk.com is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map

























