I sent them an email and they are sending me another one! Got to LOVE Birchbox customer service! :)
I sent them an email and they are sending me another one! Got to LOVE Birchbox customer service! :)
Sadly, the NUXE mask I got in my Birchbox broke me out something fierce. Although I do have wonky skin that likes to get spotty on occasion, nothing I can recollect has ever been the cause of a breakout besides hormones and genetics, so the fact that this broke me out is pretty amazing. I'm sad because I was super excited to try NUXE. I still want to try their lip balm that all the Youtube gurus rave about, but it's $20. :(

I ended up with Box 24
I'm very happy!
It's pretty and musky. Pachuli and rose. It lasts for a long time. It's kind of sexy! I really like it! I'm totally getting the sample pack to see if there's one I love more. My entire family kept sniffing me all day telling me they liked it!

Birchbox has some renewal codes:
Anyone know if it is possible to renew even though my annual sub doesn't expire until april?
I think you get a regular box. Welcome boxes are usually for 'gift subscriptions". But if it's really important to you, I would email CS to be 100% sure.
I've had Birchbox for a while now (September 2011), so I don't know if they've changed it at all, but my first box was a regular box. I did just sign up for a gift subscription, which means I got two boxes in December and both were awesome. I feel so spoiled this month! I'm sure I'll get the short end of the stick next month though, lol.
I just checked my account...I started BB in April 2011 on a monthly basis and upgraded to an annual account in March 2012...I received a regular box in April 2012...not a welcome box as if I was just starting...hope this helps :)
so just an update on Box 3, the one with the Thymes Body lotion as a sample and a lifestyle extra. I talked to one of the nice BB customer service girls and she told me that the samples were put together by request of the Brand, to see which one sold better. I guess my question is, why wouldn't they do one of those double lifestyle things like they do with other boxes? Oh well, that's the story, just thought I'd share.

so just an update on Box 3, the one with the Thymes Body lotion as a sample and a lifestyle extra. I talked to one of the nice BB customer service girls and she told me that the samples were put together by request of the Brand, to see which one sold better. I guess my question is, why wouldn't they do one of those double lifestyle things like they do with other boxes? Oh well, that's the story, just thought I'd share.
Hi there! I was wondering why there were 2 of the same brand in one box like that. Seems lame to me. Totally felt like Box 3 was a "punishment" box, did you? Maybe it's because I haven't been completing product surveys as often as I should. Whoops!

I didn't get this box, but I completely agree with you ladies. Especially because Birchbox said that the company that makes the lotion asked to have the two scents put together so that they could see which one sold better! Wouldn't it have been better for the company if you could review both scents? That way they'd have accurate feedback on both the products they're wanting you to try, not just one. Especially as it caused the majority of those who received the lotions to say they NEVER want to buy anything from this company again!
I hope BB comes to its senses and allows you all to review it.

I didn't get this box, but I completely agree with you ladies. Especially because Birchbox said that the company that makes the lotion asked to have the two scents put together so that they could see which one sold better! Wouldn't it have been better for the company if you could review both scents? That way they'd have accurate feedback on both the products they're wanting you to try, not just one. Especially as it caused the majority of those who received the lotions to say they NEVER want to buy anything from this company again!
I hope BB comes to its senses and allows you all to review it.
I did tell the CS girl something similar to this, that it would have made more sense to be able to review both or something. She basically said she'd make a note and let marketing know that I didn't like the way it was set up and that I'd never get "the same sample twice" again. I liked the lotion, I just think BB could have thrown me another extra (fortune cookie?) or something to make the box worth it. I think it was a bad call on several accounts.