or Connect
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Nice Dupe list

post #1 of 40
Thread Starter 

Hi everyone, I don't know if you guys have seen this, but I decided to publish it. It's an extensive list of dupes for eyeshadows, blushes, and glosses.

MAC eyeshadows = Milani eyeshadows
MAC pigments = NYX Loose pigments
Stila eyeshadows = Prestige eyeshadows

Here's some more specific colors that I have used before:

MAC Satin Taupe eyeshadow = Rimmel All Over Pencil in Strength
MAC Sumptuous Olive eyeshadow = Milani Antiqued Gold eyeshadow
MAC Shroom eyeshadow = Jordana in Beige eyeshadow

And here are some more knockoffs that I know of:

*Blush
NARS Orgasm blush = Milani Luminous, Cover Girl Rose Silk Cheeker, Mark Afterglo, Loreal's LE Front Page Peach
NARS Sin blush = Milani Temptation
Nars Deep Throat = Rimmel Apricot Blush
NARS Antibes Multiple = Wet 'n Wild #721 Scandalous
NARS Copacabana Multiple = Wet 'n Wild #724 Flirt
NARS Maldives Multiple = Wet 'n Wild Just Peachy
NARS Portofino Multiple = Wet 'n Wild #722 Coy
NARS South Beach Multiple = Wet 'n Wild Brazen Babe

*Eyeshadows
MAC Bamboo = Wild and Crazy Wild Guava
MAC Brill = Wild & Crazy Bahama Water
MAC Dark Soul pigment = Jane Clubbing
MAC Gorgeous Gold = Prestige Glitz C-157
MAC Juxt = Jane Rain Forest
MAC Lucky Green = Wet n' Wild Marquis
MAC Naked Lunch = Wet n' Wild Fine Wink
MAC Paradisco = Flirt! Feeling Hot
MAC Trax = Flirt! Glamourazzi
MAC Vellium = Wild and Crazy Lily Song
MAC Amber Lights = Milani Sun Goddess
MAC Black Tied = Jane Clubbing = Milani Storm
MAC Coppering = Milani Flare
MAC Dementhe, Steamy, Humid = Milani Clover
MAC Electric Eel = Milani Atlantis
MAC Guacamole = Milani Limbo Lime
MAC Jest = Milani Peachy Peach
MAC Juxt = Milani Garden Mist (juxt is lighter and yellower)
MAC Little Madame = Milani Illusion
MAC Mulch, Sable = Milani Java Bean
MAC Parfait Amour = Milani Enchantment
MAC Perverted Pearl = Milani Silver Bullet
MAC Pink Freeze = Milani Taffy
MAC Shale = Milani Icy Plum
MAC Silver Pigment = Milani Mercury
MAC Sketch = Milani Marooned
MAC Vanilla = Milani Snow Frost
MAC Vellum = Milani Moonlight
MAC Woodwinked = Milani Golden Bronze
Shu Uemura ME 945 = Caboodles Smooth
Shu Uemura P Brown 76 = Flirt Oh Please!
Stila Barefoot Contessa = Prestige Spark
Stila GoLightly = Jane Magical Mushroom eye shadow (discontinued), Milani Golden Bronze
Stila Grace = Ulta Plum Smoke
Stila Jade = Sally Girl China Doll (discontinued)
Stila Kitten = Wet n Wild Fine Wink, CoverGirl Champagne Eye Enhansers shadow, Sally Girl Silver Lining
Stila Sun = Prestige Champagne
Stila Twig = Milani Spice
Urban Decay Acid Rain = Prestige Wasabi
Urban Decay Asphyxia= Milani Enchantment
Urban Decay Midnight Cowboy = Milani Sheer Sand
Urban Decay Mildew = Prestige Iguana
Urban Decay X = Ulta Sunlight

*Lipsticks/Lipglosses
Chanel Blizzard Glossimer = Wet n' Wild Bronzeberry Gloss
Chanel Giggle Glossimer = Neutragena Chic gloss
Chanel Twinkle Glossimer = Prestige Alloy Vinylwear
Chanel Nude Liner = Max Factor Liner in Nude, Wet n' Wild #666
Clinique Black Honey Almost Lipstick = Maybelline Drippin Honey Wet Shine Lipstick
Lancome Simmer Juicy Tube= L’Oreal Strawberry Smoothie ColourJuice, L’Oreal Butterscotch Drop ColourJuice
MAC Dainty Cake Lipstick = NYC Firefly #306b
MAC High Tea Lipstick = Rimmel Airy Fairy, Milani Sheer Lipstick in Amaterro
MAC Lovechild Lipglass = Rimmel Snog Lipgloss
MAC Love Nectar Lusterglass= Milani Coral Shimmer Lipgloss
MAC Lust Lipglass= L'Oreal ColuorJuice in Passionfruit Squeeze
MAC Oh Baby Lipglass = Milani Serendipity Gloss
MAC Prrr Lipglass = L'Oreal ColourJuice in Mai Tai
MAC Plum Liner = Revlon Colorstay Plum liner
MAC Sequin Lipstick = Almay Sequin One Coat Lipstick
MAC Spice Liner = Wet n’ Wild #666 or #712 Liner
NARS Orgasm Lipgloss = NYC Sungold Lipgloss, Mary Kate and Ashley Truly Lipgloss
NARS Pillow Talk Lipgloss = Rimmel Vinyl Lip Star in Be A Star
NARS Turkish Delight Lipgloss = Neutrogena MoistureShine in Groove
Scott Barnes Flossy Glossy in Meow = Neutrogena Groove Moistureshine
Stila Apricot Lipglaze =Prestige Fuzzy Navel Jet Stream Gloss
Stila Jane Lipstick = Rimmel Birthday Suit Lipstick

*Brushes
MAC #187 Stippling Brush = Flirt! Skunk Brush

post #2 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

That is a nice list thanks!!
post #3 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Thanks for the great list!!

And might I add another one:

Nars Orgasm Blush= Mark Good Glowing Blush in After Glow
post #4 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

oooh, good to know! thanks for the info!
post #5 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

great list, thanks for sharing, I jotted a few down for when I'm next at the drugstore
post #6 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Thanks.
post #7 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Originally Posted by ag10v View Post
Thanks for the great list!!

And might I add another one:

Nars Orgasm Blush= Mark Good Glowing Blush in After Glow
That one's on there already!
post #8 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Great list!! Thnx alot!!
post #9 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

I hate that Milani isn't sold where I live
post #10 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Originally Posted by AprilRayne View Post
That one's on there already!

I completely missed it!!
post #11 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

nice !! thanks ! too bad i can only get my hands on some prestige stuff.
post #12 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

awesome thanks!
post #13 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

wow....great list
post #14 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Hi:

Great list. Thanks for posting.
post #15 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

You can add: Nars Orgasm = theBalm Hot Mama (more pigmented and less shimmery though)
post #16 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

This list is so great.
post #17 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Thanks so much for compiling this list! Will have to check a couple of these out!
post #18 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

yay! can't wait to try some of these products out!!!!!
post #19 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

great list
post #20 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Thanks so much for this great list!
post #21 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Anyone try to go to Makeupforlife.com, I don't see where the blog is, I must be blind!!
post #22 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

LIPSTICK LOOKALIKES

Aveda
Original: Aveda Matte Huckleberry Lipstick
CopyCat: Bonne Bell Autumn Rose

Original: Aveda lipstick in Sheer Ambrosia
CopyCat: Clinique lipstick in Black Violet

Original: Aveda lipstick in Tupelo
CopyCat: Elke lipstick in Java

LIPSTICK LOOKALIKES

Avon
Original: Avon Triple Benefit Lipstick in Rosetone
CopyCat: Estee Lauder All-Day Lipstick in Rose Sapphire

Bobbi Brown
Original: Bobbi Brown Beige Gold Lipstick
CopyCat: L'Oreal Hip Honey

Original: Bobbi Brown Blackberry
CopyCat: Revlon SuperLustrous Blackberry

Original: Bobbi Brown Garnet Shimmer
CopyCat: MAC O

Original: Bobbi Brown Pinkberry Stain
CopyCat: Prestige Berry Stain

Original: Bobbi Brown Nude
CopyCat: Revlon Pro Neutrality Cream
Comments: The GB looks exactly like the BB but in a gloss. Results may vary.

Original: Bobbi Brown Raisin
CopyCat: L'Oreal Colour Supreme lipstick in Real Raisin
Comments: If you're not put off by the smell of L'Oreal lipsticks, (yuck!) you can snag a classy color for cheap.

Original: Bobbi Brown Redwood
CopyCat: Revlon Pro Burnished Cream

Bourjois
Original: Bourjois Beige Noir
CopyCat: Chanel Beige De Chanel

Chanel
Original: Chanel Beige De Chanel
CopyCat: Bourjois Beige Noir

Original: Chanel Berries
CopyCat: Jane Best of Berries

Original: Chanel Black Red
CopyCat: DCA #115

Original: Chanel Gold
CopyCat: Cosmetic Factory's 24 Karat

Original: Chanel Metallic Vamp Lipstick
CopyCat: L'Oreal Mica
Cosmetic Factory Metallique

Original: Chanel Midnight
CopyCat: Cosmetic Factory 12 a.m.

Original: Chanel Rouge Noir Lipstick
CopyCat: Wet'N'Wild Blackest Red

Original: Chanel Vamp
CopyCat: Wet'N'Wild Blackest Red

Christian Dior
Original: Christian Dior's Jazzy Brown
CopyCat: Lancome Raisinette or Matte Raisin

Original: Christian Dior's Rose Souffle lipstick
CopyCat: Loreal's Tendre Mauve (color riche)
Comments: Loreal's lipstick is THE SAME AS Dior's.It's the same--color, texture, scent/taste.

Clinique
Original: Clinique Berry Buff
CopyCat: Cover Girl Coco Blush

Original: Clinique Lipstick in Buff
CopyCat: Bonne Bell lip Gear Citrus City
L'oreal Tawny

Original: Clinique Black Honey Almost Lipstick
CopyCat: Bonne Belle Grapevine Whine lip gloss
Bonne Bell Grapevine Whine Lip-Lix
Bonne Bell Cin-a-Money
Prestige Sheer Grape
Aveda lipstick in Sheer Ambrosia

Original: Clinique Double Fudge Lipstick
CopyCat: Lord & Berry Sheer Mocha

Original: Clinique Heather Plum
CopyCat: Almay Serene

Original: Clinique Nude Ice
CopyCat: Jane Megabites in Pineapple Delight

Original: Clinique Sweet Honey
CopyCat: Jane lipstick in Rosy Outlook

Original: Clinique Tenderheart
CopyCat: Natural Glow Wood Hyaicinth
Elizabeth Arden Breathless

Cover Girl
Original: Cover girl -spice it up
CopyCat: Jane flipstick #3 Solar flare

Elke
Original: Elke Tribal
CopyCat: Stila Ina

Elizabeth Arden
Original: Elizabeth Arden Breathless
CopyCat: Clinique Tenderheart

Estee Lauder
Original: Estee Lauder Baby Shimmer
CopyCat: DCA #113

Original: Estee Lauder Bare Buff
CopyCat: Maybelline Nude Lipstick

Original: Estee Lauder Double Matte Lipstick
CopyCat: Cover Girl's Self-Renewing Lipstick in Toasted Almond
Comments: The Estee Lauder lipstick is $15.00, opposed to the CG lipstick with is about $4.00.

Original: Estee Lauder Inocence
CopyCat: The Cosmetic Factory's Naive

Original: Estee Lauder All-Day Lipstick in Rose Sapphire
CopyCat: Avon Beyond Color Triple Benefit Lipstick in Rosetone

Original: Estee Lauder Sheer blackberry (Lipblush)
CopyCat: Origins Bite Your Lips in Raspberry

Original: Estee Lauder Sheer Bronze(Lipblush)
CopyCat: Origins Bite Your Lips in Brownberry
(a tiny, tiny difference

Original: Estee Lauder Sheer Ruby (Lipblush)
CopyCat: Garden Botanika Sheer Lipcrayon in Sheer Garnet (discontinued)
Origins Bite Your Lips in Strawberry

Garden Botanika
Original: Garden botanika Apple Blossom
CopyCat: Prestige beigy pink

Original: Garden Botanika Saffron
CopyCat: Nat Robbins Rosewood

Original: Garden Botanika Sheer Sheer Garnet Lip Crayon (DISCONTINED)
CopyCat: Estee Lauder Lipblush in Sheer Ruby

Original: Garden Botanika Sassafras Lip Crayon
CopyCat: MAC Lame

Original: Garden Botanika Walnut lip pencil
CopyCat: Origins Clovebud Sheer Stick

Guerlain
Original: Guerlain Jacinthe
CopyCat: Stila Carver

Hard Candy
Original: Hard Candy Pussy Cat Lipstick
CopyCat: Maybelline Pink Perle

Jane
Original: Jane's Night Shift
CopyCat: Revlon Super Lustrous Bold Berry

Lancome
Original: Lancome Exotique
CopyCat: L'oreal Brown Sugar

Original: Lancome Lilas Metallique Lipstick
CopyCat: Wet'N'Wild 548A

Original: Lancome Matte Raisin
CopyCat: Christian Dior Jazzy Brown

Original: Lancome platinum
CopyCat: jane's "go platinum

Original: Lancome Raisinette
CopyCat: Tropez's Buttered rum
Christian Dior Jazzy Brown

Original: Lancome Violine
CopyCat: Lord & Berry's Intense Plum
Ethnique lipstick in #528
Victoria's Secret Black Plum
Revlon Violet Extreme
Comments: Ethnique cosmetics are found at Dollar Stores. The Ethnique is a bit drier and has a touch more red in it than the Violine. Unless you compare the two side by side, it's impossible to tell the difference.

Laura Mercier
Original: Laura Mercier Very Bitten
CopyCat: Jane Flipstick in Jammin'

Lorac
Original: LORAC Ashley
CopyCat: Bath & Body Works 'Canyon'

MAC
Original: MAC Bubbles
CopyCat: Wet'N'Wild #516A

Original: MAC Carnal
CopyCat: Cargo Congo
L'OREAL Wine and Dine

Original: MAC Cherish
CopyCat: M Professionals Nameless

Original: MAC Cyber
CopyCat: Manic Panic's Black Witch

Original: MAC Del Rio
CopyCat: Cosmetic Factory Brazil
Necessites-LeeAnn

Original: MAC Delish
CopyCat: Wet'N'Wild Ice Cream

Original: MAC Desire
CopyCat: Professional Makeup Company (M) Venom

Original: MAC Diva
CopyCat: Jane's "Really Raisin
Comments: The Jane version is creamier & you can't beat the price. ( $2.49)

Original: MAC Film Noir
CopyCat: L'Oreal Colour Endure Hot Fudge
Garden Botanika's CatTail

Original: MAC Flavour
CopyCat: Maybelline Nude Pink
Comments: Both are nude pink beige shades. Very similar.

Original: MAC Florien
CopyCat: Elke Classic Mauve

Original: MAC Freeze
CopyCat: Cosmetic Factory Chilly

Original: MAC Frenzy
CopyCat: Revlon Bamboo Bronze

Original: MAC Frou
CopyCat: Bonne Bell Vanilla Volts

Original: MAC Grid Lipstick
CopyCat: Bonne Bell LipGear in Traffic Jam

Original: MAC Haku
CopyCat: Wet n' Wild's lipstick #546-A
Comments: . A $1.50 compared to $14.50 is a real find.

Original: MAC Haze
CopyCat: M Professionals Wild Thing

Original: MAC Hyper
CopyCat: Revlon Granite

Original: MAC Lame
CopyCat: Prestige's Lipstick in Sorbet
Garden Botanika Lipcrayon in Sassafras

Original: MAC Lust
CopyCat: Maybelline Great Wear Silver Lilac
Revlon Virtual Violet

Original: MAC Media
CopyCat: M Professionals Indulgendence

Original: MAC Modum
CopyCat: Almay Malt

Original: MAC O
CopyCat: Bobbi Brown Garnet Shimmer

Original: MAC Odyssey
CopyCat: Bonne Bell Lip Gear in Berry Bash

Original: MAC Paramount
CopyCat: Necessities-MacDaddy
Garden Botanika's Mahogany

Original: MAC Pervette
CopyCat: Jane HipLips Pink Slip

Original: MAC Prism
CopyCat: Garden Botanika Rose Sage

Original: MAC Rubine
CopyCat: Cosmetic factory- Ruby Red

Original: MAC Spirit
CopyCat: Cosmetic Factory Angel

Original: MAC Touch
CopyCat: Jane Browned Down Red
TBS Vanillia stick

Original: MAC Twig
CopyCat: Avon Twig
Prestige VIP

Original: MACs Viva Glam II
CopyCat: Jane flipstick-Roseland
Maybelline Lipstick Great Wear Flesh

Original: MAC Wuss
CopyCat: Avon Spice
Wet 'n Wild--#547A

Original: MAC XS
CopyCat: Cosmetic Factory Extra
Wet 'n Wild--#506A

Manic Panic
Original: Manic Panic 'Tramp'
CopyCat: Lip Savvy 'Black Orchid'

Max Factor
Original: Max Factor Lipsilk #10
CopyCat: Max Factor lasting color in 'UV fusion'

OPI
Original: OPI How To Jamaica Million Lipstick
CopyCat: Wet'N'Wild Arctic

Origins
Original: Origins Bite Your Lips in Brownberry
CopyCat: Estee Lauder Lipblush in Sheer Bronze
Original: Origins Clovebud Sheer Stick
CopyCat: Garden Botanika Walnut lip pencil
Prescriptives Chocolate Kiss (discontinued)

Original: Origins Shimmer Stick in Ginger Ale
CopyCat: Lord & Berry Lipstique in Glaze

Original: Origins Malt Stick
CopyCat: Maybelline Lip Express in Coffee Run

Original: Origins Bite Your Lips in Raspberry
CopyCat: Estee Lauder Lipblush in Sheer blackberry

Original: Origins Bite Your Lips in Strawberry
CopyCat: Estee Lauder Lipblush in Sheer Ruby

Prescriptives
Original: Prescriptives Blackberry Suede
CopyCat: Revlon's Blackberry
Original: Prescriptives Chocolate Kiss (Discontinued)
CopyCat: Origins Clovebud sheer stick

Original: Prescriptives Grape Stain Lipstick
CopyCat: Prestige Sheer Grape

Original: Prescriptives Mystery Lipstick
CopyCat: Almay Anti-Chap lipcolor in Softly

Revlon
Original: Revlon Glossing
CopyCat: Wet 'n' Wild Lipstick 541 Nouvelle

Original: Revlon Super Lustrous Bold Berry
CopyCat: Jane's Night Shift

Smashbox
Original: Smashbox Smashing Nude
CopyCat: Elke Oasis

Stila
Original: Stila Andi Lipstick
CopyCat: MAC Hyper
Revlon Granite
Original: Stila Carver
CopyCat: Guerlain Jacinthe

Original: Stila Helen
CopyCat: Prestige Nuts lipstick

Original: Stila Ina
CopyCat: Elke Tribal

Original: Stila Luce Lipstick
CopyCat: Cover Girl Raisin Glaze
Revlon Deep Nude
Jane's Browned Down Red
NatRobbins Brandywine

Original: Stila Piaf Lipstick
CopyCat: Clinique Black Lily

Original: Stila Robin
CopyCat: Naturistics mechanical lipliner in nude

Three Custom Color Specialists
Original: Three Custom Color Specialists Cool Salmon
CopyCat: Max Factor's Silksticks #50

Original: Three Custom Color Specialists Cool Brown
CopyCat: Nat Robbins "Coffee"

Original: Three Custom Color Specialists Cool Brown
CopyCat: Max Factor's Sepia

Urban Decay
Original: Urban Decay Gash
CopyCat: Revlon Street Wear All Over Pencil in Blood

Look-a-Likes
post #23 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Great List! I putting a copy in my purse
post #24 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

That's a great list! Thanks!
post #25 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

I love dupe lists! Luckily I have many of those bargain brand knockoffs!
post #26 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

I cannot wait to try out some of these goodies!!!! I just don't know where to start!!!
post #27 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Originally Posted by Aquilah View Post
You can add: Nars Orgasm = theBalm Hot Mama (more pigmented and less shimmery though)
I was about to add that! I saw it today, more product, more pigment, and less $ than Orgasm.
post #28 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

i can't wait to try out some of these dupes!
post #29 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Nice list!
post #30 of 40

Re: Nice Dupe list

Great lists. I'm all for saving a bit of money wherever I can. I'm really gutted though that I can't get Milani in the UK. Or at least that I know of. I've heard so many good things about this brand. I'd really like to try some of their stuff out.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Makeup Talk