Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
zadidoll

Re: elizabethhaze

Recommended Posts

I wanted to update people on the matter with elizabethhaze since it's now apparent that at least four to five people have been burned by her. Normally we wouldn't discuss the matter with those not involved in the situation however due to the fact that I still have people coming to me about it I figured I'd make a public "announcement" so there are no rumors and misinformation passed around.

 

Elizabethhaze account has been restricted and while she is free to post in other areas of the website she cannot see the Buy, Sell, Trade forums. This was done due to the fact that I have received those complaints and after reviewing the matter and discussing it with my moderator staff I felt it was in the best interest of our members to restrict the account.

 

For those of you with pending trades with her please keep in mind she is in Canada so while mail between countries is slow it does not take three or more weeks. I've received a package from a fellow member here who also lives in Canada and she had mailed it out in December and I received it within a week of her mailing it. I sent a package to Canada and that took nine days counting the weekend.

 

Also, I want to make you aware the other issue that has been presented to us is that the MAC items she has for trade are counterfeit. I've had to previously delete some of her trade posts because the products she was showing looked to be counterfeit - more specifically the MAC Venomous Villains blush - she had posted was a counterfeit. MAC made four blushes - one for each villain - and the official one with the Evil Queen was called Bite of an Apple. The one she had for trade she called LOL. This is her image from one of the deleted posts:

 

600x400px-LL-c64e1d6b_IMG_97912 - Copy.jpeg

 

Her blush looks more like this one which is from a known site that sells counterfeit MAC and counterfeit Urban Decay products:

 

mac-makeup-mac-cosmetics-mac-venomous-villians-blush-8-styles_4-49499.jpg

 

 

You can't really tell from that image however the positioning of the Evil Queen is in the wrong spot and the color of the blush is wrong. This is what the real blush looks like:

 

review_vvevilqueen037.jpg review_vvevilqueen040.jpg

 

We know for sure that the blush is counterfeit because she did do a trade with another member here that did go through and that person provided us with more images of the counterfeit including the fact the blush she got was numbered instead of named.

 

If anyone else has done a trade with her and either never got the items or received counterfeits please let us know. We do take the matter seriously and if there are more complaints then I will be letting our site owner decide what other steps to take.

 


These images - below - were what our member sent us in regards to the counterfeit MAC Evil Queen blush.

 

015.JPG 014.JPG

 

As she pointed out the real MAC did not come with a compartment for a blush brush and would be labeled Bite of an Apple and not 04.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Update: Another person has PMed me stating her trade with Liz did go through but the items she got were counterfeit and when she contact Liz, Liz was adamant that it was legitimate products. I know when I first approached Liz - when I removed her trade posts - that she (Liz) was adamant she bought the items at her local MAC because her sister worked for MAC or something like that. If anyone else DID get items from Liz please PM me the images.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am in no way affiliated with this situation, but just wanted to say I like this method of discussing these types of issues. I think it's best to "vent" and provide evidence to a moderator who can look into it and publicly share it with the forum in an unbiased, appropriate way. I know I personally do look at trader feedback before I agree to a swap, but I have also heard countless times that people choose not to leave any feedback out of fear of receiving spiteful feedback in return. 

For example up until yesterday this user had nothing but one positive feedback so I would not have hesitated going into a trade with her not knowing 5 or 6 people were having bad experiences.  

 

I think if users had the assurance that they could dispute feedback left on their profile out of spite (assuming they have proof) they might be more willing to leave negative feedback when they have a bad experience. If I'm not mistaken it is against site rules to leave untrue or malicious feedback, right? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes it is. If the feedback left was done so in an attempt to bully another person we can delete the negative feedback SO LONG as we have proof of some sort that it was a vindictive feedback.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by zadidoll View Post

 

Yes it is. If the feedback left was done so in an attempt to bully another person we can delete the negative feedback SO LONG as we have proof of some sort that it was a vindictive feedback.

Of course. I don't believe everyone is aware that while the trades are 100% at their own risk the site does enforce strict rules to protect them from vindictive behavior. I think it's also best to encourage users to purchase delivery confirmation and/or take photos of their packages and postage receipts so in the event they do need to dispute something they will have solid proof that they are not at fault. Maybe if users could come to the moderators at the first sign of red flags you all would be able to catch onto repeat offenders more quickly and in a private manner? Perhaps we could make a thread about proper procedure to report issues with trades and feedback as well as how the site will protect users from bullying?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by Fairest of all View Post

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by zadidoll View Post

 

Yes it is. If the feedback left was done so in an attempt to bully another person we can delete the negative feedback SO LONG as we have proof of some sort that it was a vindictive feedback.

Of course. I don't believe everyone is aware that while the trades are 100% at their own risk the site does enforce strict rules to protect them from vindictive behavior. I think it's also best to encourage users to purchase delivery confirmation and/or take photos of their packages and postage receipts so in the event they do need to dispute something they will have solid proof that they are not at fault. Maybe if users could come to the moderators at the first sign of red flags you all would be able to catch onto repeat offenders more quickly and in a private manner? Perhaps we could make a thread about proper procedure to report issues with trades and feedback as well as how the site will protect users from bullying?

 

That's a good idea. I'll review the current policies we have for the B/S/T area and possibly update the rules as needed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The eyeliner I received from her was fake. I didn't know at first since I didn't own any MAC products but after hearing others were screwed by her I looked into my product (which I never ended up using because it was too hard for my eye). I learned it was extremely fake and told her. She said she bought it off of E-bay. I'm not at my house to take a picture of it but this is exactly what it looked like: 450

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If there is one thing MUT has taught me, is to pay attention to any make up I pick up. I never knew there were such things as fake name brand cosmetics. o.O

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If there is one thing MUT has taught me, is to pay attention to any make up I pick up. I never knew there were such things as fake name brand cosmetics. o.O
I had no idea either. I always just thought, "Wow, what a great deal! I'm so lucky!" :rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, that is indeed a fake MAC eyeliner. I may not buy MAC but I still know enough about the line. If and when I buy MAC it's directly from MAC even though I hate to pay full price. Better full price for a legit product than half price for a fake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Wow, that is indeed a fake MAC eyeliner. I may not buy MAC but I still know enough about the line. If and when I buy MAC it's directly from MAC even though I hate to pay full price. Better full price for a legit product than half price for a fake.
I 100% agree! Initially I wasn't trading her for makeup, but for Kinder Surprise Eggs since you can't get them here in the US. She offered to throw in the 'MAC Eyeliner' and I took her up on it because hey, it's MAC! So I threw in even more products to make up the difference for the eyeliner. Failll.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've only had one real swap and it turned out fine, thankfully. But I know now to be leary when it comes to HE brands.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by Pancua View Post

 

I've only had one real swap and it turned out fine, thankfully. But I know now to be leary when it comes to HE brands.

 

After this, I've become extremely wary of online trades or buying through Amazon or ebay. I've decide I'd much rather just save money and pay full price for a product and be certain its legit. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have fortunately only had good swaps so far. Thank you to everyone on MUT who helped to get back to the official feedback method. Thank you zadidoll for your work trying to help protect us to the extent you can. Ladies, when trading with someone with little to no feedback, don't be afraid to wait to ship your end until you get a tracking number or a photo of the package with postage and your address on it. Make it known what your personal standards are for trading and lots of dishonest people will just steer clear of you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

These were sent to me via email from a member here. I won't name who but these lipsticks and lipglosses she was sent from Liz. These are obviously fake as MAC never labels their products with numbers.

 

Click to enlarge images.

 

mac fakes 01.jpg mac fakes 02.jpg

 

If you did get ANY MAC from Liz do NOT USE. It's counterfeit and potentially dangerous.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you did get ANY MAC from Liz do NOT USE. It's counterfeit and potentially dangerous.

 

 

Why do you think that it´s dagerous? Because of the ingredients?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by Lisa Simpson View Post

 

 

Why do you think that it´s dagerous? Because of the ingredients?

 

With counterfeit products, there is no way of knowing what went into it or how it was made. A lot of counterfeit makeup has heavy metals, such as lead in it. Here's a news article that sums things up nicely:

 

http://www.insideedition.com/news/8192/inside-edition-investigates-counterfeit-makeup.aspx

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Glad I saw this - I almost bought a "MAC" lipstick off of her, but decided not to because she was selling @ $15. at that price, it's practically what MAC sells it for. (the one I wanted.) she contacted me later inquiring about an inter nation trade but didn't respond to my response. glad I dodged a bullet there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i just did a trade with elizabethhaze i sent my products out on (day)03/(month)06/(year)12 and i emailed her on the 13th of june to ask if she received the products cause i still didnt receive mine and she said no so i just figured it was taking a long time well the date 2day is 19th of june and i still havent received anything so i took the tracking number and entered it into the canada post website and it said she recived the package on the 7th of june... you see my concern cause i sent her and email on the 13th and she said she didnt receive it and the tracker is saying she did receive it on the 7th!!!! and i havent received my package yet and i live in canada and so does she so it shouldnt have takin this long i dont think.. see also this is my first swap ever so im kinda disapointed... :( also the day i sent her package she told me she sent hers too so i think i shoulda received it by now... and now i dont know what to do i sent her an email asking for the tracking number but i havent received and email yet im not saying she didnt send it or anythign im just saying if she sent it when she told me she did then i really think i shoulda received it by now.. so i guess i just have to wait and see...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes i am new to this site and my first ever swap was with elizabethaze and know after reading everyones feedback im worried cause i still havent got my products and i know she got hers so i dunno.. i dont know if i will ever swap again and it sucks cause i was sooo excited and i sent her some really good stuff so im still trying to have faith that she really did send me a package and its just taking forever to get here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most likely you've been scammed. If she got the package on the 7th and you haven't received anything as of today (the 19th) she's probably not going to send you anything. *IF* you do then it most likely is counterfeit MAC since that's what she has sent out to those who did get their trade packages from her. Since you're in Canada you have a better case than those who are not. Contact your local post office to see if you can file some type of mail fraud charges against her and depending on the value of the items you sent to her contact the police in her area and in yours to file a report. Enough people do that the cops might be able to do something.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

update on the liz situation she contacted me and said she put the wrong postage on my package so it got sent back to her and then she didnt get a chance to resend and wasnt sure if she should cause of all the negative comments on here cause she just  became aware that the mac stuff was fake so she wasnt sure if she should send it to me or not so we are disgusing what to do next. so things are going ok for now and we are working something out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by MyraRzepa View Post

 

update on the liz situation she contacted me and said she put the wrong postage on my package so it got sent back to her and then she didnt get a chance to resend and wasnt sure if she should cause of all the negative comments on here cause she just  became aware that the mac stuff was fake so she wasnt sure if she should send it to me or not so we are disgusing what to do next. so things are going ok for now and we are working something out.

 

I call BS on the whole matter and here's why. She told me and a couple of other people she bought the items at her local MAC store. If she did the items would be legitimate not counterfeit so she lied about buying the things from MAC so I don't believe her when she said to you the items came back to her because postage was wrong. The decision to go through with it is up to you OR you can request the items back you sent her OR the cash value of the items sent. Any way you dice it she's not to be trusted at all. Good luck with your decision and let us know what you decide to do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • NARS Cosmetics Shop Cargo Cosmetics Today!


  • Posts

    • Everybody wants to have good clothes because it creates our image. This is very important for women because they are really worried about their look and they can see More details at Mau-fashion.com to be fashionable. At least, it helps me to build my looks and my unique style. So, good luck 
    • Cách giúp phục hồi nhanh khi bị chấn thươngNgày nay, với công nghệ hiện đại đạt tiêu chuẩn của Tổ chức Y tế thế giới, vị thuốc huyết giác đã được chiết tách và bào chế thành thuốc thảo dược dưới dạng viên nang. Thuốc được dùng các trường hợp: sưng đau, bầm tím, bong gân, chấn thương do va đập, tập luyện thể thao, giúp giảm đau nhanh và làm tan các vết bầm tím.Với các vết thương hở ngoài da như trầy xước, vết cắt, thuốc giúp vị trí tổn thương nhanh khô, chống viêm, chồng phù nề hiệu quả, nhanh lên da non, liền sẹo. Với trường hợp chấn thương nặng cần can thiệp bởi phẫu thuật nên dùng thuốc trước và sau phẫu thuật để giảm nguy cơ nhiễm trùng và nhanh phục hồi. Mọi thông tin hãy nhấn vào link : https://tinyurl.com/y5dwtxly
    • You can have a vegan diet. I've been a vegan for 2 years already. I was obese before I started and right now I am perfectly happy with my weight. I have the right weight for my height. So, yea. Try to go vegan.
    • I use photoshop and canva for logo design and I'm loving it!
    • I personally think that there nothing wrong with wearing light make up. It's just our way of feeling good about ourselves and definitely not to impress guys. 

About MakeupTalk®

© 2003-2018 MakeupTalk.com®, an active online community and message board geared towards members wanting to discuss everything to do with makeup, cosmetics, product reviews, monthly subscription boxes and general beauty related topics. Our community provides product reviews, makeup and general beauty tips. Our most popular topics are subscription boxes and their monthly spoilers. Join our community for free to take part in the conversations and share your own beauty tips and product reviews with others. We look forward to seeing you online here at Makeuptalk®!

MakeupTalk® Facebook

×