Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
zadidoll

Birchbox: December 2012

Recommended Posts

so just an update on Box 3, the one with the Thymes Body lotion as a sample and a lifestyle extra. I talked to one of the nice BB customer service girls and she told me that the samples were put together by request of the Brand, to see which one sold better. I guess my question is, why wouldn't they do one of those double lifestyle things like they do with other boxes? Oh well, that's the story, just thought I'd share.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I got a box with the Thymes lotion...one bottle and one packet...if they really wanted to compare they would have put the same sizes (preferably bottles) instead of comparing apples to oranges.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If they truly wanted a comparison they should have atleast let us do feedback on both..instead of screwing us out of feedback points!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by jaimelesmots View Post

 

so just an update on Box 3, the one with the Thymes Body lotion as a sample and a lifestyle extra. I talked to one of the nice BB customer service girls and she told me that the samples were put together by request of the Brand, to see which one sold better. I guess my question is, why wouldn't they do one of those double lifestyle things like they do with other boxes? Oh well, that's the story, just thought I'd share.

 

Hi there!  I was wondering why there were 2 of the same brand in one box like that.  Seems lame to me.  Totally felt like Box 3 was a "punishment" box, did you?  Maybe it's because I haven't been completing product surveys as often as I should.  Whoops! 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If they truly wanted a comparison they should have atleast let us do feedback on both..instead of screwing us out of feedback points!
Yes. That. ^ I am ticked off about not getting to reviee the little foil packet. I mean, we are forced by Birchbox to review foil packets quite frequently, but we got 4 legit samples and then got screwed out of 10 points, basically. Just my opinion. I know it might be a little harsh, but I am quite ticked off about it. I got box 3 as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by peridotcricket View Post

 

 

Yes. That. ^ I am ticked off about not getting to reviee the little foil packet. I mean, we are forced by Birchbox to review foil packets quite frequently, but we got 4 legit samples and then got screwed out of 10 points, basically. Just my opinion. I know it might be a little harsh, but I am quite ticked off about it. I got box 3 as well.

I didn't get this box, but I completely agree with you ladies.  Especially because Birchbox said that the company that makes the lotion asked to have the two scents put together so that they could see which one sold better!  Wouldn't it have been better for the company if you could review both scents? That way they'd have accurate feedback on both the products they're wanting you to try, not just one.  Especially as it caused the majority of those who received the lotions to say they NEVER want to buy anything from this company again!

 

I hope BB comes to its senses and allows you all to review it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by magicalmom View Post

 

I didn't get this box, but I completely agree with you ladies.  Especially because Birchbox said that the company that makes the lotion asked to have the two scents put together so that they could see which one sold better!  Wouldn't it have been better for the company if you could review both scents? That way they'd have accurate feedback on both the products they're wanting you to try, not just one.  Especially as it caused the majority of those who received the lotions to say they NEVER want to buy anything from this company again!

 

I hope BB comes to its senses and allows you all to review it.

 

 

 

I did tell the CS girl something similar to this, that it would have made more sense to be able to review both or something. She basically said she'd make a note and let marketing know that I didn't like the way it was set up and that I'd never get "the same sample twice" again. I liked the lotion, I just think BB could have thrown me another extra (fortune cookie?) or something to make the box worth it. I think it was a bad call on several accounts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For those that got the Benefit Eye Cream, how are you getting the product out? I used my pinky at first to get a bit but now I have to go on an angle and my (short) nail touches... Ew. Months ago, Beauty army did little spatulas that I thought were dumb and I never got one.. Now that I have a tiny little pot of cream I wish I had it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by bluemustang View Post

 

For those that got the Benefit Eye Cream, how are you getting the product out? I used my pinky at first to get a bit but now I have to go on an angle and my (short) nail touches... Ew.

Months ago, Beauty army did little spatulas that I thought were dumb and I never got one.. Now that I have a tiny little pot of cream I wish I had it!

I like to use a q-tip to get stuff out of little pots..works good!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by Scooby384 View Post

 

I like to use a q-tip to get stuff out of little pots..works good!

This is what I do as well (and then the gray kitty tries to steal the Q-tips because he likes things he can carry around and flip in the air, but that's a whole different mess!).  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
For those that got the Benefit Eye Cream, how are you getting the product out? I used my pinky at first to get a bit but now I have to go on an angle and my (short) nail touches... Ew. Months ago, Beauty army did little spatulas that I thought were dumb and I never got one.. Now that I have a tiny little pot of cream I wish I had it!
I actually saw a tiny beauty spatula at CVS the other day! I can't remember the brand, but there were a bunch of them hanging next to an end cap in the beauty department. It even has a little lip on one edge to get product from under the ridge of a bottle or screw-top container. I think it was like $2 or so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This is what I do as well (and then the gray kitty tries to steal the Q-tips because he likes things he can carry around and flip in the air, but that's a whole different mess!).  
My grey kitty does the same thing!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I finally got my December birchbox I got box1 and im extremely happy with it.

 

bb box 1:

12 benefits instant healthy hair treatment

Emily's chocolate chocolate covered fortune cookies

Fresh citron de vigne rollerball

Sampar ultra hydrating Fluid

The Balm hot mama

The only thing that could have made this box better for me would have been mary lou manizer instead of hot mama.

 

 

This box was definitely an upgrade from my welcome box in November.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bought the full size of the cc cream and after several consecutive days of trying it I think I am going to end up returning it. Goes on nice enough and skin feels good but the coverage is just not there. I found myself using twice as much as my regular BBs and still not getting anywhere near the coverage. I went back to one of my regulars today and that just clinched it. Sorry, Juice Beauty...I do like some of your products from this line, but this one is a fail for me. :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I bought the full size of the cc cream and after several consecutive days of trying it I think I am going to end up returning it. Goes on nice enough and skin feels good but the coverage is just not there. I found myself using twice as much as my regular BBs and still not getting anywhere near the coverage. I went back to one of my regulars today and that just clinched it. Sorry, Juice Beauty...I do like some of your products from this line, but this one is a fail for me. :(
I was very disappointed with the coverage, too. Everything else was decent, but felt like I was putting moisturizer on my skin and not a very good tinted one lol. I'll be sticking to my BB cream for now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right! I just called for my return label. I would rather have the points back to use for something else I like but can't/won't typically otherwise afford (like the pricey Stem Cellular Moisturizer which I have sampled and really liked). I love that Birchbox has a good return policy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Originally Posted by Jackieblue View Post

 

I bought the full size of the cc cream and after several consecutive days of trying it I think I am going to end up returning it. Goes on nice enough and skin feels good but the coverage is just not there. I found myself using twice as much as my regular BBs and still not getting anywhere near the coverage. I went back to one of my regulars today and that just clinched it. Sorry, Juice Beauty...I do like some of your products from this line, but this one is a fail for me. :(

Me, three.

 

Both the Juice Beauty CC Cream and the new Urban Decay BB Cream are nice feeling - but litte/no coverage.  I'd rather they market these as healthy primers but I'm guessing that wouldn't be fashionable given how popular BB/CC creams are.  

 

That said, both make really nice primer/moisturizers, so you could combine two steps if you wear foundations... but I'd rather stick to my "coverage" BB creams instead.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • NARS Cosmetics Shop Cargo Cosmetics Today!


  • Posts

    • I didn't tryied the vitimin C serum cream for my skin, I think it very harsh when you are using it at your skin so it would be hard for me to have it I will try something else..
    • Today was pay day. I paid $22.90 extra on my credit card. I realized I'm now halfway done with my goal for the month - to pay $100.00 toward my credit card (including minimum payment). It's halfway through the month, so I am right on track! I made a $30 payment last week. I got deodorant, the only beauty item I need to replace. I ended up not getting the fancy new Secret or an Avon set, but just regular Secret Paris Rose from Dollar General. It was $5 - I thought that was a little high in price. I had this deo before during my No Buys, so it's a tradition. I didn't feel like spending extra or taking the time to order online. Too lazy to fill out the order pages! I sure am out of practice shopping! 
    • What am I wishing for right now? Yesterday I was looking at the Yves Rocher French website to see if they have anything new that might come to the US. I found something to love, but not a thing this time. In France, Yves Rocher has special salons. They have some fabulous sounding treatments. One I really fell in love with was an eyebrow treatment. They put eye patches under your eyes, then while those are on, they shape the eyebrows. After all is done, they apply an eye cream. That's what I'd love right now, and I suppose I could copy it at home with what I already have. 
    • It feels like it has been January for a long time, but we're only halfway through the month. There's still time to do a lot of things this month!  I have some empties! I finished my three DHC foil packets, the two mini micellar waters from my Yves Rocher Advent Calendar, and my Neutrogena Shampoo mini.  Now using up: June Jacobs Green Tea and Cucumber Shampoo mini Freeman Cucumber and Pink Salt Masque packet MAC Strobe Cream mini in Pinklite - This is a really nice cream that has a bit of pink color corrector and a bit of luminosity. It's great for a no makeup routine! Very pretty, and feels wonderful on the skin. I got it in an Ipsy bag.  I had the Freeman cucumber masque in my project use it up in January 2018. Now I have another one to use. There is a lot of product in the packet. It is enough for several weeks of use. But it is a clay masque, so it gets dry and messy in the packet. I recall having a hard time using it all up before. So I opened the packet all around the edges, and used a spatula to transfer the contents into an empty jar so it will stay fresh and be easier to use up. I'm looking forward to using it with my new masque brush! I will be having some fun masque and movie nights!     
    • The best concert I have ever attended was by Bohemia: the Punjabi Rapper. He was in Delhi (Lajpat Nagar) He is my favourite Artist and Rapper. When I saw him for the first time, my soul felt bliss ❤️ All the crowd of fans were going insane about him I can't forget that moment and want to attend more and more of his concerts

About MakeupTalk®

© 2003-2018 MakeupTalk.com®, an active online community and message board geared towards members wanting to discuss everything to do with makeup, cosmetics, product reviews, monthly subscription boxes and general beauty related topics. Our community provides product reviews, makeup and general beauty tips. Our most popular topics are subscription boxes and their monthly spoilers. Join our community for free to take part in the conversations and share your own beauty tips and product reviews with others. We look forward to seeing you online here at Makeuptalk®!

MakeupTalk® Facebook

×