MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil

MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in shade "Engraved" I used this Only once only on my upper lid only & I felt like I liked UD Pencils better so its a shame I bought this and won't be using this. I paid $16 in Macy's for it - make me an offer whatever price you feel would be appropriate and hopefully we can come to an agreement! Any questions just ask me! I never sharpened it - this is exactly how it came and looks after I only use it once only on my upper eye lid (not in my eye just above) 

thanks!