Jump to content
Reija

Birchbox April 2015 (Spoilers)

Recommended Posts

If they're going to call it different samples of its a different scent then you should definitely at least still get to review it and get points. I would email them because I know if it was me that would really annoy me.

 

I'm definitely going to email them.  The number of times I've had to get in touch with them lately is insane.  I returned an item (first time I've ever done that) and it took like a month and a half (and like 3 sets of emails) to get credit back, and then this box is just such a disappointment.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm definitely going to email them.  The number of times I've had to get in touch with them lately is insane.  I returned an item (first time I've ever done that) and it took like a month and a half (and like 3 sets of emails) to get credit back, and then this box is just such a disappointment.

I emailed them about getting the Whish shave cream again since I also got it in May of last year and they gave me 50 points and told me they would look into it for me. It is showing that I can review it for points though so thats nice!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've also used the L'Oreal Everpure line and it's really good. I've also used the OGX line, I loved the Argan Oil one, but there are a number of other formulas in that line. Both can be found at Walmart and are really inexpensive. I'm now using Living Proof Perfect Hair Day line and loving it, but it is more expensive. 

I like Organix too. I am using the Moroccan oil when I do not want to over-use my Kerastase Elixir Ultime, it's kind of a dupe. I also used the OGX Keratin shampoo-conditioner, they smelled nice and were okay shampoo-conditioner.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow my sub boxes are failing this month.

Supergoop eye cream

Ojon hair oil

Not soap radio

Jane iredale PYS

Harvey prince body butter

 

Eye cream boring and tiny. I don't use hair oil. I have 2 not soap radio already. I already got a HP body butter. The only thing i want is my PYS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hmm...

 

So before the 10th, my box was showing a bunch of stuff I didn't want other than my sample choice.

Now..my box is completely different, and has 2 of the 3 sample choices in it...but not the one that I reserved.

 

So confused.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm getting:

 

Jouer Cream Blush

Jane Iredale Lip and Cheek Stain

Paula's Choice Vitamin C Spot Treatment

Beaver Shampoo

Beaver Conditioner

 

I'm excited about the Jouer because I was trying to pick between that and the Jane Iredale (my PYS) for awhile. I'm also excited about the Paula's Choice product because I haven't tried anything from that line and have heard nothing but good things about it. Not excited about the Beaver products. Also, my upgrade is Lord and Berry mascara and a nailpolish. Not excited for that lol.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got my box today and used the Beaver shampoo. It smells like a cross between Pantene and Finesse. They came in rather large sample bottles. I have curly hair and have to wash it a lot over the summer when it's too hot to iron, so these will get used.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got my box today and used the Beaver shampoo. It smells like a cross between Pantene and Finesse. They came in rather large sample bottles. I have curly hair and have to wash it a lot over the summer when it's too hot to iron, so these will get used.

Are there any sulfates in the shampoo? I am getting this sample as well, but if there are sulfates, I will have to pass it on to a friend.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got my box today and am so in love with the Rifle Paper Co plus items that I received. I got the tote and the tumbler/notebook set. So cute! My box contained:

 

Jouer Tint

Laqa Lip Lube in Honeypot

Harvey Prince Yogini

Beaver Shampoo and Conditioner

 

Pretty good, and I'm always excited to try new shampoo and conditioner, so I'm looking forward to washing my hair tomorrow with these, despite the creepy name. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got my box today, overall fairly happy with it, I'll probably use everything. I do subscribe to try new things so will give them all a go. I really like the Jouer tint, I received a shade called Petal. The Whish I'll give a try, it's in coconut and at least smells good  :) . I have to say the box is very pretty this month. Happy I didn't get the Beaver shampoo  :D    

 

 

post-119138-0-29387500-1428791911_thumb.gif

 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Been lurking but coming out of my lurkiness to say that I have 3 subscriptions and all 3 of them got the beaver shampoo and conditioner  :wacko: . One of my boxes is possibly getting a duplicate of a June 2014 same brand AND same shade. The Laqa lip crayon bubble pink. I know that it is a possibility of duplicates between boxes but this is just very unfortunate. Will post next time with the box contents of all 3. I pys and got one of each in each of the 3 boxes. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Box 1:

Popsugar eyeshadow palette

Clean Perfume

LAQA lip pencil (Will email if it shows up as the same shade as June 2014)

Beaver Shampoo

Beaver Conditioner

 

Box 2: 

 

Whish Shaving Cream (Stop trying to make Whish happen)

LAQA lip pencil (same shade but can't complain because on this account never had this shade)

Jouer Tint

Beaver Shampoo 

Beaver Conditioner

 

Box 3:

La Fresh Body Soother

Beaver Shampoo

Beaver Conditioner

Jane Iredele Lip

Havvy Hello Butter (Another brand that need to stop trying to happen)

 

Will be cutting down my boxes down to 2 because again know duplicates can happen but any one of those boxes would be very unimaginative. Box 3 has a Body butter and Body soother. I would have loved the fekkai new spray, new hair growth, or any of those. Ironically my skincare routine is paula's choice and buy it through birchbox but I never get the paula's choice :(.The PYS saves the boxes. 

Edited by crescentmoon
  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems like almost all of us are unhappy with our boxes and people who upgraded also are not happy with the products. They started shipping boxes (especially with upgrades and plus items) much later, some people didn't even receive their March boxes before April. I wish Birchbox took one step at a time and integrate the new addition into their working system before they go ahead and add another branch. I think they are now overwhelmed with the upgrade and plus, that's why they are not paying enough attention to our profiles to select appropriate samples with no duplicates. Hope it will get better soon :)

I wonder if any of you (who received the Beavers already) ended up liking the Beaver shampoo and conditioner after using. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I opened a 3rd account, simply to get the referral points on my ACE (1st) account. I chose Iredale on 1st account as PYS, no PYS on 3rd account --- received the exact same box!

 

I was mad at first but it turned out pretty good - love two items and really like the other three! :)

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was in Ulta today and they have Whish now ... like every type of product and every scent that Whish makes (except Blueberry, which is still a Birchbox exclusive), including post-shave wax, which I did not know was a thing for people other than men who shave their entire scalp every day.  Holy crap, I did not know they had such a variety of crap.  I loved the Blueberry shave cream when it first came out.  Then I realized it clogs my razor like nothing else and it's really a pain in the butt to use.  It does an amazing job, for shave cream, but the rinsing the razor for a full 30 seconds and sometimes shaking the Hell out of it  between swipes is just too much.  

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Whish Shaving Cream (Stop trying to make Whish happen)

 

Oh goodness, I lost it laughing at this comment. This is how I feel, too!! :laughno:

 

Got my box today and am so in love with the Rifle Paper Co plus items that I received. I got the tote and the tumbler/notebook set. So cute!

 

Do you think you got value for money with the tumbler and notebooks? And does the brand name on the tote bother you? I seriously wanted that tote, but the name on the bottom right was a huge turn off for me.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was in Ulta today and they have Whish now ... like every type of product and every scent that Whish makes (except Blueberry, which is still a Birchbox exclusive), including post-shave wax, which I did not know was a thing for people other than men who shave their entire scalp every day.  Holy crap, I did not know they had such a variety of crap.  I loved the Blueberry shave cream when it first came out.  Then I realized it clogs my razor like nothing else and it's really a pain in the butt to use.  It does an amazing job, for shave cream, but the rinsing the razor for a full 30 seconds and sometimes shaking the Hell out of it  between swipes is just too much.  

I actually got the Whish hair inhibiting gel and body butter with 2 stacked 20% (40% off) coupons from Ulta right after I received the first body butter from them. I actually really like the way they all smell, and the lavender, which is the one I got, is almost a dead ringer scent-wise for these homemade lavender-vanilla marshmallows I make to go in hot chocolate.

Edited by artemiss
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was in Ulta today and they have Whish now ... like every type of product and every scent that Whish makes (except Blueberry, which is still a Birchbox exclusive), including post-shave wax, which I did not know was a thing for people other than men who shave their entire scalp every day. Holy crap, I did not know they had such a variety of crap. I loved the Blueberry shave cream when it first came out. Then I realized it clogs my razor like nothing else and it's really a pain in the butt to use. It does an amazing job, for shave cream, but the rinsing the razor for a full 30 seconds and sometimes shaking the Hell out of it between swipes is just too much.

Yes! I work at Ulta and I am SO happy that they sell whish now! I loooove the body butter and hair inhibiting gel.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually liked the Beaver shampoo. It does have sulfates but my hair tends to get oily (think Prof. Snape). I just can't do sulfate free. It smells a bit like Pantene without that waxy provitamin stuff. That being said I think it was overkill to have it in so many box combinations. Next month I am going with a curated. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually liked the Beaver shampoo. It does have sulfates but my hair tends to get oily (think Prof. Snape). I just can't do sulfate free. It smells a bit like Pantene without that waxy provitamin stuff. That being said I think it was overkill to have it in so many box combinations. Next month I am going with a curated.

Bummer :( at least 3/5 of the box has potential

 

Oh well, I will pass it on to a friend :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I loved the Blueberry shave cream when it first came out.  Then I realized it clogs my razor like nothing else and it's really a pain in the butt to use.  It does an amazing job, for shave cream, but the rinsing the razor for a full 30 seconds and sometimes shaking the Hell out of it  between swipes is just too much.  

I received the Acai Grapefruit scented shave cream last summer and really liked it so I used some points and ordered a full sized Coconut scent. After the first few shaves I realized it wasn't that great and wholly rice krispies, it kept clogging my shower drain. Gross.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I received the Acai Grapefruit scented shave cream last summer and really liked it so I used some points and ordered a full sized Coconut scent. After the first few shaves I realized it wasn't that great and wholly rice krispies, it kept clogging my shower drain. Gross.

That's so weird! I've seen similar reviews of the shaving cream but I am in love with it! I have repurchased the Lotion/Shaving Cream set in the Almond scent 3 different times because I love it so much. The body butter is my favorite of the two, admittedly, but the shaving cream doesn't clog my shower or my razor, really. I do rinse my razor repeatedly anyway when I'm shaving though, so maybe that's why. I just can't get enough of the almond scent LOL I think that's it's biggest draw for me!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have an email out to BB customer service on this one, but I am totally baffled.

 

My box arrived and I used the Whish body butter in blueberry that was included. The card said body butter, it was body butter in the box...but when I went to review it, BB says they sent me shave cream.

 

I can certainly review the scent, but it seems misleading to review the body butter in the shave cream section, but that is the only way I get the points.

 

I hope customer service sorts this one out. Ugh.

 

I want to review this one too, because all day I could not figure out what the smell reminds me of. It was driving me a little nutty.

 

I finally figured it out! It smells like liquid amoxicillin. You know, the pink stuff you have to force down your kids when they are sick and need an antibiotic? Smells exactly like that! Speaking as a mother, it is not a calming, happy scent. I have worn it involuntarily a few too many times, LOL. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have an email out to BB customer service on this one, but I am totally baffled.

 

My box arrived and I used the Whish body butter in blueberry that was included. The card said body butter, it was body butter in the box...but when I went to review it, BB says they sent me shave cream.

 

I can certainly review the scent, but it seems misleading to review the body butter in the shave cream section, but that is the only way I get the points.

 

I hope customer service sorts this one out. Ugh.

 

I want to review this one too, because all day I could not figure out what the smell reminds me of. It was driving me a little nutty.

 

I finally figured it out! It smells like liquid amoxicillin. You know, the pink stuff you have to force down your kids when they are sick and need an antibiotic? Smells exactly like that! Speaking as a mother, it is not a calming, happy scent. I have worn it involuntarily a few too many times, LOL. 

Yuck! I am not excited (even more than before) about receiving the shave cream in my box after hearing about the smell :/

 

I hope I will receive the body lotion instead of shave cream. I do not use shave creams, but I do love body lotions. I use those body lotion samples from Birchbox as hand cream to carry in my purse. They are the perfect size for that :)

 

You can still review, but say no to the question about using it yet. In this way you will still get the points without misleading anyone. 

Edited by pearldrop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • NARS Cosmetics Shop Cargo Cosmetics Today!


  • Recent images in this topic

  • Posts

    • No Buy Program Guide   I found a great new No Buy channel on YouTube (well it found me; it was in my recommended videos), a new No Buy channel from a New York concert pianist, Natalia Lavrova. I find this fascinating, because I love the world of classical music. Here is someone in my dream life, who loves shopping, and beauty subscriptions, who has credit card debt, and is doing a No Buy! I'll be fascinated to watch this channel and hear how this artist's No Buy goes as she is preparing for concert tours abroad! Ms. Lavrova has a really good Shop My Stash video with great tips on winter makeup colors, like icy pink highlighter. I looked for her piano performances on YouTube and they are stunning. This is going to be a big inspiration for me!   
    • I made it through the night with no buying! I slept through the shopping craving like it was an illness. I woke up after the 12 hours of sleep and as I was waking up I thought of a happy time in the 90's. I was young; all my family members were alive. I was at a Bond film, Tomorrow Never Dies, (I love James Bond and don't know what I am going to do when his new film is released, since I'm not allowed money for entertainment on my No Buy). On the floor near my feet was a big bag of Estee Lauder products that I had just gotten with my birthday and Christmas money. I had a full size moisturizer and a huge PWP, beautiful. The film had a great ending. The Bond girl was underwater, running out of air, and just in time, there's James Bond, the theme music resumes! Great scene! And walking around the mall after, how happy I felt! And today I am sad that time is gone, many family members are gone, life is sadder, time is running out, and I did not use that bag of Estee Lauder products up! I probably used them a few times and then threw them out and bought something else. And maybe if I had used every drop, in my mind, I could have held on to life, to time, to happiness. At any rate I would have had more money. If only we knew about No Buys and Project Pans then! This is just one of a million examples of how I think about this.  When I woke up Elle S was still analyzing her samples! She was talking about how her project taught her to evaluate (excellent video, Oct 1, 2017).  Last night in bed I took some photos of samples I need to use up. Sorry for so many long posts, but I've really had to work on this for the last 24 hours. Primers, shower gels and body scrub, toners, and masques.   
    • I haven't given in and bought anything yet, though I wanted to. I went to bed early (I think it was 5 pm), and I was listening to Elle S 365 Days of Samples playlist on YouTube. It is inspiring. Elle is detailed, persevering, and creative. I was very cozy, and I dreamed I was going to a spa in Europe. I was so excited about the spa, and about the skin care products the spa was going to have in the room for us. My mother was going with me, and I told her I was going to bring a minimal amount of beauty products in my suitcase, because we would be getting some from the spa. When I woke up I was sad, because the dream was so nice. Now I just woke up and I'm hot and thirsty, but the craving to shop has gone down somewhat. Before I went to sleep I looked in my sample boxes. I saw a beautiful mini lotion with a gold bow on the package that I got for Christmas and had already forgotten about. The glittery gold bow sparkled beautifully in the light.  This while experience today of realizing I have been on No Buy so long without realizing it has been interesting. I have been keeping busy with other things. I began going to a a new religious congregation a month after I went back on No Buy (a different religion I wanted to learn about for a long, long time) and have been busy with that, and have been making new friends and socializing more. The new religion is one that fills my need for intellectual and artistic (through its liturgy) stimulation. I've met wonderful people. It's not always easy to keep going there, as I'm shy and reclusive, but I've kept it up. Maybe this is what made the time go so fast without me knowing it.  I guess I'll go and listen to some more 365 Days of Samples.   
    • I'm changing the way I keep track of the time on my No Buy in order to motivate myself more. I didn't realize until today that I'm in month 8 of my second year! Four and a half months until completion of Year 2! I want to finish my mini sample products by June 12, 2020. Here is a partial inventory: Shampoo minis - all used up! Face cream, and face cleanser minis - all used up after a great deal of work and patience!  Mini body scrubs - 1  Mini shower gels - 7 Mini face primers - 8 Mini toners - 9 Mini face masques - 12 I still have to add up mini body creams, hair conditioners, and perfumes. I should reorganize them all to get a new perspective.   
    • Today is the test - will I pass or fail?  Two years ago at this time (end of January 2018, on a Sunday), I discovered Hannah Louise Poston videos for the first time. She had just begun her channel. I recalled cleaning my room while watching the videos and feeling very inspired about my No Buy. I was inspired for an entire year, until ... One year ago at this time (end of January 2019, on a Sunday), I was feeling down. The weather was very bad. There was no good food in the house. I started watching haul type videos. I decided to buy something I didn't need. I felt HORRIBLE and just went on a binge. I tried to hard to get back on the path, but couldn't. I didn't get back on the path until June, when I came back with renewed vigor and had huge success for the rest of the year.  I have been thinking, why don't I just let go again, today? After all, last year I let go and did not ruin myself that much, and then by summer, like a miracle, I was back on No Buy and finished all my goals for the year and more. So I'm using that as justification for cheating. I do have shopping cravings right now. Still, I have not used half of the nice things I got on my binge last year. What will I do? Will I relive 2018 or 2019?  ______ Several hours later. I still want to shop. I cleaned a bit while watching the very first video of Hannah Louise Poston, which was published on January 15, 2018 (Introducing My No-Buy Year!). Watching that brought back a lot of good memories. At the 10:00 mark of this video, Hannah was taking about still being in the exciting early phase of the No Buy, with packages still coming in the mail from the last fling before, and it all being new and not the long haul yet. Then I realized I'm not in the early phase, I'm in the long haul now. I looked at my diaries and realized that I am already halfway through the eighth month of my second No Buy year! It has actually been that long since I began again on June 12! I only have four and a half months to complete in my second No Buy year! I really had no idea I was so far along. So while the calendar year is young, it's August as far as my No Buy Year 2 is concerned. The second year of No Buy goes quickly! I still want to shop, but now I am looking at things differently, and may feel less tempted.   

About MakeupTalk®

© 2003-2018 MakeupTalk.com®, an active online community and message board geared towards members wanting to discuss everything to do with makeup, cosmetics, product reviews, monthly subscription boxes and general beauty related topics. Our community provides product reviews, makeup and general beauty tips. Our most popular topics are subscription boxes and their monthly spoilers. Join our community for free to take part in the conversations and share your own beauty tips and product reviews with others. We look forward to seeing you online here at Makeuptalk®!

MakeupTalk® Facebook

×