I got my box today, after I canceled it in June and their customer service is pretty terrible. Apparently I was billed already for July, and they shipped the box already. So they sent an email yesterday saying my sub was canceled and they issued a refund; but by that time the box was already nearly here. So I guess I got a free box. After I opened it though I did like it better than the last few months, I decided to keep the mascara and try it. I got the Ofra eyebrow pencil, which I like but I have so many already.