I second the Burts Bees. They just came out with a full coverage lipstick line that is really moisturizing and lasts a pretty long time. The colors are gorgeous too. It's a satin finish, which looks like the look you're going for. I'm sure they have a color like the one above. They've got about 12-15 colors in the range I think. Maybe Fuchsia Flood?
Check out the swatch! I think it's a pretty close match!
Thanks for the suggestions! I'll look into them! I haven't heard of some of them brands /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> Sadly I don't consider burts bees cruelty free because they're owned by Clorox who test on animals :/