Can you recommend a chunky crayon eyeliner?

I am looking for one of the chunky, crayon-type EL that really works well. I normally use Almay's retractable type soft pencil EL & while they work well for me, I would like a different look and want to use one of the fat crayon types. I have tried the loose MMU ES & even with UD Shadow Primer & Pure Luxe gel EL primer (after moisturizing well, using foundation on my EL & ES) I have issues with the loose EL separating and leaving little spots/patches. I am older, have normal-dry skin, so I am going to assume that is why. I tried one of these chunky ones from Avon but the EL kind of "spreads" under my eyes but otherwise I love it - just want something that is chunky, creamy, easy to apply, and stays put.

I use Benefit's Bad Gal Liner its a chunky crayon & works great

MUB Monet, could you tell me where you buy this & about how much it costs? I am really a newbie when it comes to MU. I wore it some times for many years but never have I gotten into MU like I have the last several months so even well known brands are not always real familiar to me.

I am open to drug store brands as well (Rite Aid, Walgreen - no CVS anywhere near me) since I can try MU from them & return it if they don't work for me. Love that policy!

I love the chunky crayons from BarryM. They're really soft.

Thats the Bad gal liner. It's 20 dollars and I get mine from Macy's because it has a Benefit counter.

Are you looking to use them as eyeliners, or for eyeshadows?

NYX has those thick eyeliner/eyeshadow crayons. They're very smooth and creamy, but some people have had problems with them creasing because they're so creamy + they have oily eyelids.

MAC Shadesticks are the crayon type too...but they've discontinued a lot of the colors. Some colors are not smooth at all, like Gentle Lentil, but colors like Beige-ing and Sharkskin are much smoother.

shu umera has 2 sticks that have 3 colors in them each wtih various colors that are very crayon-like.

NYX has those crayon thingies, and so does L'oreal HIP.

MAC has shadesticks that I consider crayons...

Sephora has crayon pencils too...

Hi:

I see someone already recommended Benefit's "Bad Girl". Sephora Brand also has chunky pencil liners. I have a couple by Rimmel.

There is a new one that you may want to try out by Revlon from their Beyond Naturals collection!

Oh, and I remember reading some good reviews for Sue Devitt's pencils.

NYX Cosmetics jumbo eye pencils work great!

i would also recommend NYX Jumbo or Avon Big Color or Sephora

NYX jumbo pencils always crease like crazy on my greasy eyelids even when I use MAC Paint Pot under them as a base.

Avon's Big Colors are not bad and they don't crease with a primer (I have oily lids), but they are not super pigmented.

bad gal liner ftw

L'oreal HiP has some...I think they're called "Cream Color Crayons" or something. They work really well and last a long time on me =]

I use NYX! =)