If I were to get ONE eyeshadow pallette at Sephoras...

Which one would you recommend?

I already have a gold-ish eyeshadow [Prestige in Golden Retriever], a basic black smokey eye trio from L'Oreal, and a neutral-ish trio from WnW [Egypt Sands]. I want to expand into more colors, but nothing too neon or over the top. Hopefully something thats high quality yet REASONABLY PRICED.

Two of the options I was looking at are:

Sephora: Pop Beauty Eye Class - Smokey Eyes: Eyeshadow Sets

Pop Beauty Eye Class - Smokey Eyes [12 colors, $32]

Sephora: TheBalm Shady Lady Eyeshadow Palette: Eyeshadow Sets

Shady Lady Eyeshadow Palette. [9 colors, $38]

Sephora: Pop Beauty Smokey Rose Wallet: Gift Ideas & Palettes

Pop Beauty Smokey Rose Wallet. [12 eyeshadows, 4 blushes, 2 lip glosses, brush, $42]

http://www.sephora.com/browse/product.jhtml?id=P211635&categoryId=B70

Kat Von D True Romance Eyeshadow Palette - Ludwig

[8 colors, $34]

I'm asian with brown eyes and black hair, so I need something that would be flattering on me. It would mostly be used during dances [senior year of high school, baby!] and a little during the day, although I really just rely on my Prestige eyeshadow for that.

Anyone want to help me choose between the two, or suggest something else?

Thanks!

http://www.sephora.com/browse/produ...D4CV0KRRQIGQ?id=P204726&_requestid=452322

Either theBalm or Kat Von D. I have only heard iffy reviews of pop beauty products.

I'd suggest Urban Decay's Book of Shadows...i love it.

I really love Urban Decay palettes I have the Deluxe box and the Amo and love them both!

I love Urban Decay palettes as well!

If choosing from your list, though, I'd go with the Kat Von D.

Thebalm shadows in that palette are wonderful... I have all of the shades in the palette in full size eye shadows... I love each and every one of them.

I have the Kat Von D one too... it's really nice. I want the new "Metal Orchestra" one.

My favorite palettes that just came out though... the Urban Decay Book of Shadows, and Lorac's Croc case. Amazing.

from your list, I've heard the Kat von d has really good reviews

i like the first pop beauty one and the kat von d one.

the first one you have more options. and the kat von d one is more nuetral

thats cool

Pop Beauty's palettes are really hit and miss, so I wouldn't go that route if it's the only thing you're getting.

has anyone tried the pop beauty palettes in question? or compared them with the others on my list? :]

i don't have a sephoras near me so i have to buy online D:

oo wow i would go with the balm or kat von d one!!

but i keep hearing alot about the UD book one...

Sephora: Tarte Eye Couture Day-To-Night Eye Palette ($182 Value): Combination Sets

Eye Couture Day-To-Night Eye Palette ($182 Value)

what about this one?

Originally Posted by summerxdreams /img/forum/go_quote.gif Sephora: Tarte Eye Couture Day-To-Night Eye Palette ($182 Value): Combination Sets
Eye Couture Day-To-Night Eye Palette ($182 Value)

what about this one?

I have it, and LOVE it! The shadows are so smooth, and very pigmented. The liner that comes with it is great too. The best part is it comes with a little tutorial card that teaches you amazing combos. I highly recommend this one.

The only thing is it's $44. For 8$ more you can get Tarte the Vanity... and with that you get a Park Ave. Princess bronzer... and many more shadows... plus all of the glosses and the mascara.

Sephora: Tarte The Vanity Limited Edition Palette ($494 Value): Combination Sets

I have that too... again, the shadows are super-smooth and pigmented. The only thing you don't get is the tutorial.

oh, nice! is it really bulky? because it looks HUGE and i want something i can travel with :]

and how is the quality? there are a couple of comments that the bigger set has lower quality eyeshadow?

it says it is a $494 value? whats up with that? I got to get this, thx for posting

I would say the BALM or Kat Von D.

I'd go with the Kat Von D. Although I prefer the Beethoven palette since I'm cool toned, but Ludwig is nice too. Another suggestion is Urban Decay, their shadows have good payoff