I know I may get shunned for this, but you may be "over-caring" for your skin. Some people have stronger or less sensitive skin I think but not me. I know when I religiously wash my face twice a day and then moisturize my face got much worse. It was peeling AND oily. I started steam washing my face in the morning by running my face under nice hot water for a few minutes in the shower, without using cleanser. I only exfoliate once a week, never more. I do not scrub my face with any pads, I wash with my hands only. I wash my face with Cetaphil towards the end of the day to remove makeup. Obviously if I get particularly dirty I may have to wash more than that but this is usually plenty. I have super sensitive skin and I found that with all the washings, even with ultra gentle cleansers, it was too much. Within a week of changing to this I found that my skin was almost completely repaired and looking brighter. Not sure if this will work for you but it's an easy thing to test and not costly.