It seems to me that it'd make your nails seem shorter, since the crescent kind of becomes a new cuticle (which doesn't "count" as a nail, to me visually anyway), instead of a normal french, where the crescent becomes a new tip of the nail (even if your nails are super short) giving the illusion of longer nails. (If I've got 9 long nails and one cut short because it broke, a french makes it look like I've still got a nail tip, even though it doesn't actually go past my fingertip)
The first one has obviously longer nails and it doesn't look so bad, but the latter two actually have decent length (they're not that short, actually) but the nails feel stubbier, kind of like if they had just been cut all the way down. (The middle one moreso actually. They have the appearance of nails that are entirely short, but you can visibly see they actually extend past her fingertips.)
So if your nails are long enough, I think it could work as something different, but if you've got normal length or shorter nails, it'd just make your nails and fingers look stubby.
