I wanted to bump this up in hopes of more replies as I too am in search of my HG MMU Foundation.
I started with a couple drug store brands first (Maybelline, Physician's Formula & a couple others I can't recall ATM). I then discovered EDM which in the beginning I was happy with but my skin seemed to get even more dry as time went on & I never could get the coverage I really had hoped for OR a shade that truly matched & I did try just about every shade & all the formulation samples. I didn't realize 'til month's later how off the shade I was wearing was when I started taking photos comparing MMU on me & even just looking in the mirror at how they all reacted differently on me. So, I decided I needed to sample some other brands which I did (Lumiere, Joppa, UglowGirl, & Alima). I have Silk Naturals samples on the way.
So far, with Alima, I have found a very good foundation match (N3-very forgiving too) with my first order as well as the coverage (buildable) which I have been seeking. I found a great shade of blush too & am sampling more. Their blushes & ES give me the soft look I want as well. I don't have trouble with staying power with any of these items but I do have normal-dry skin so that probably impacts that. I just love how all the products seem so creamy on my skin.
I find it kind of odd though that when I have tried using different brand blushes with the Alima (EDM for one-which I have a lot of), they enhance my pores.
I had some issues with the EDM MU doing that anyway as well as enhancing lines thus another reason for a need for change). I think I will be able to use the EDM ES but I may actually like Alima's formulation a little better- too soon to say yet.
Am looking forward to trying the SN. If that doesn't work as well as the Alima, then I will order some full size Alima foundation & Blush & more samples of ES as I may have found my HG (I know I go back to alima after trying each new sample brand as I like it SO much better than any that I tried so far).
Edited to say - I think one of the most important things I have learned about MMU is that "one size does not fit all".
I think each individual's chemical MU, skin type, etc., can make all the difference as to whether a MMU works well for us or not. For that reason, I find for me that it is difficult for me to tell someone else whether a brand/company will work on their skin unless we have very similar skin but still their skin could react totally differently than mine to it. I guess the best I can do is just share my own experience based on that.
Sorry this is so long - & thank you for taking the time to read this.