My favorite mascara for a curling effect is Sublime De Chanel in Deep Black. The problem for me is that it's not sold in the US. My first tube came as a gift with purchase in Canada and my second tube was a purchase I made at duty free on the way home from Mexico. It drives me absolutely batty that this amazing mascara is available in other parts of North America but not here in the states. It is truly the most amazing mascara I've ever used. Chanel, are you listening??