Box Monthly? Scam?

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Feb 26, 2011
Messages
20,866
Reaction score
1,361
Location
USA
So one of my Facebook followers PMed me about Box Monthly and was concerned about it due to the poor customer service and the products looking to be old and/or from EBay. I think I have heard of Box Monthly or I might just be confusing the format with Makeup Monthly since it's the same idea.

Considering we just dealt with Posh Pod, which in the end turned out to have been a scam since they were buying products from EBay for their "Pods" and were also sending out counterfeit M•A•C products, I did take a look at Box Monthly and noticed it's set up on Wordpress and that the boxes look to be cheap with a homemade label stuck on (you can see that the label looks to have been roughly cut to fit the box).


From their blog:

http://boxmonthly.com/

For only $12 a month you get the best new Luxury beauty full sized items and healthy treats for your bag.

In reality the price is $17 a month because they charge for shipping.

From the About page:

Lori Peters comes from a Television and advertising background. I have followed TV celebrities from the “Today†show to movies. I know all kinds of celebrity secrets from beauty tricks of the trade to anti-aging trends, to how to eat healthy and feel good inside and out and I want to bring them to you. I review beauty products, attend fashion shows and movie premiers, try out hair salons, hair products and health foods. I have a social media and writing background. I also am a life coach. I can talk to you about how you’re feeling and what’s on your mind. I believe a woman needs to love herself from the inside out. Ask me anything. &I’d love to write for you, talk to you and meet for coffee. We are looking for new sponsors and investors. We are on the move. Contact:
For someone with a social media background, much less a writing background, her website looks unprofessional, messy and alarm bells are just ringing for me about them just based from their website. IT screams Posh Pod all over again for me. Now I'm not saying she IS a scam but from what I was told that one of her customers was blocked from posting on her wall for asking questions about the July box.

From the July box I see a Macadamia Natural Oil hair packet along with an Eyeko eyeliner... both of which came in different beauty boxes (Macadamia Natural Oil hair packet from Test Tube and Eyeko from Birchbox).

One of her subscribers received the July box and the box wasn't sealed, the products were leaking everywhere, one was EXPIRED food,  as well as dirty plus the inserts appeared to be homemade printouts and when she contacted the owner of the company the owner told her to unsubscribe if she was unhappy and went on about how expensive it is to mail the products but not a word about replacing any of the broken, damaged or expired products! Personally looking at the site and hearing about that one nightmare has cemented in my own head that this is one company I do NOT want to deal with.

Anyone here a member of Box Monthly? If so did you get your July box? Pictures?

 
I purchased the July Box the other day, and then cancled my re-occuring payment from Pay Pal.

I sent her an email asking if I would get the July box and she replied YES.

As soon as I cancled my re-occuring PayPal payment I got an email asking why.

I found it odd and after I read somemore information on reviews Im glad I did.

I can give a review of products and photos when it comes.

Lisa

Here is the email: (read from the bottom up)

 

If you resubscribe we could refund the money for July payment so you are not charged twice.  It's easier if we have it straight for the records so we know how many we need for August boxes.   Thanks.   Lori Peters Boxmonthly -------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: JULY BOX...


From: Date: Thu, July 26, 2012 8:08 pm
To: [email protected]

I meant to cancel ********* and I canceled the wrong payment and it said I can't retract it that I have to resubscribe.
Should I do it when the august boxes go out so I don't get charged twice for july.

 

----- Reply message -----
From: [email protected]
Date: Thu, Jul 26, 2012 7:27 pm
Subject: JULY BOX...

To: "L. Hi Lisa:   Why did you cancel payment?  You just joined.  Please let me know.  I was excited to have you as a member.   Regards,   Lori Peters Founder Boxmonthly.com
 
box monthly is definitely one of the sketchiest sites I've ever seen. Doesn't even look like they are trying to make it look legit...

 
That email is odd to say the least. On one hand I'm glad she's keeping an eye on her customers but at the same time... that's kind of creepy. Only time will tell if they're another Posh Pod.

 
I'm all for giving a new business some help....

I will update (here) when the box comes (with photos) so others can see if it is legit/and give my opinion.

Hope so...$17 is not the end of the world, what would bother me more is to have someone scam me.

For now I have the July box scheduled to be send and not a re-occuring account.

 
Pass! Looks a bit sketchy to me. If I want food samples, I'd go to Costco lol. Not trying to knock the foodie subs, but I want makeup/beauty only things. I'm also not interested in products being recycled/overlapped between subs. I get enough of that between BB and SS.

 
I say pass on it! I gave them a shot and hated it. It's like everything in there was thrown in as fillers. This is from the "What companies do you subscribe to" thread.

Originally Posted by Dalisay /img/forum/go_quote.gif

So my update:

Cancelled Boxmonthly...

I got my first box from them.... 

700

-Pureology Precious Oil Versatile Caring Oil

-Enjoy Life Mountain Mambo not nuts! Seed and Fruit Mix
-Healthy To Go Green Energy Tea Fusion
-Soft Lips SPF 15 in Pearl
-Jesse's Girl in Eye Dust
-Be Yourself: Everyone Else is Already Taken

I'm not gonna lie, i was expecting to be disappointed. As soon as i opened this box, I cancelled. Good thing it was an easy cancel. Thank you paypal. 
 
Jesse's Girl? Really?! I don't think Jesse (the owner of Jesse's Girl) does subscription boxes, that is work with them. I spoke with him (and I have a post coming up on their upcoming products) at CPNA and he didn't seem to know what beauty box subscriptions were. Odd.

 
I am a representative of Boxmonthly and did immediately reply to the customers request.  The product you are referring to is Pureology Precious Oil and it was sent from the company and is perfect.  The snacks are also from a company and they are good till 2/13 so it is not true that they are expired at all.  I refunded her money, because she was upset and that's what she asked for.  I was not aware of anything breaking.

The box was sent the items in a priority box from the post office and I assume something happened in the delivery process in the handling from the post office.  Boxmonthly is open to suggestions about alternative packaging and ideas.  We also are looking for people to work with us.  

This was not listed as purely a beauty box and we were integrating other features into it as the concept is for women to feel good about themselves as well as look good.  

 
Hmmmmm...... well the Pureology Oil will more than pay for the box and I probably would have purchased the product for a friend.

We shall see...

 
For $17 a month it doesn't seem worth it for me so I will pass. Then again I'm pretty much over all subscription services at this point.

 
On the website, it states that the rate is promotional. Do you plan on raising the monthly charge? I guess you could always inquire about what the damage was, in reference to expired or leaking/damaged products. Also, I'm curious as to what else you might think to include for future boxes. I'm not really interested in food based boxes, but wouldn't mind those kind of things as "extras" on occasion, like Birchbox does.

Originally Posted by Boxmonthly /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I am a representative of Boxmonthly and did immediately reply to the customers request.  The product you are referring to is Pureology Precious Oil and it was sent from the company and is perfect.  The snacks are also from a company and they are good till 2/13 so it is not true that they are expired at all.  I refunded her money, because she was upset and that's what she asked for.  I was not aware of anything breaking.

The box was sent the items in a priority box from the post office and I assume something happened in the delivery process in the handling from the post office.  Boxmonthly is open to suggestions about alternative packaging and ideas.  We also are looking for people to work with us.  

This was not listed as purely a beauty box and we were integrating other features into it as the concept is for women to feel good about themselves as well as look good.  
 
I received my Boxmonthly today and was disappointed.  Things were stuffed in the box and seemed very hodge/podge.

I received:

-Pureology Precious Oil Versatile Caring Oil

-Enjoy Life Mountain Mambo not nuts! Seed and Fruit Mix
-Healthy To Go Green Energy Tea Fusion - (2 of them)
-A barrette that has CZs making 3 flowers with 3 stones on each side (it looked used, no residue on it, but the black paint on the barrette was wearing off in several places)
-Anne Marie Borlind Mascara
-Wisdom for the Sole minibook
-A coupon for Plentils -A Self Esteem award printed on 8 1/2"x11" paper made out to my first name dated 7/22/2012 -A flyer from "Enjoy Life-Eat Freely" products (Looks like the Plentils and the Mountain Mambo are products in this line.)   Thinking of canceling the Paypal preauthorization after my head stops itching.  Having kids in school and getting possibly used hair accessories screams LICE to me.  Most likely me being paranoid, but my head is still itchy!   ICK
 
Originally Posted by PaulaG /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I received my Boxmonthly today and was disappointed.  Things were stuffed in the box and seemed very hodge/podge.

I received:

-Pureology Precious Oil Versatile Caring Oil

-Enjoy Life Mountain Mambo not nuts! Seed and Fruit Mix
-Healthy To Go Green Energy Tea Fusion - (2 of them)
-A barrette that has CZs making 3 flowers with 3 stones on each side (it looked used, no residue on it, but the black paint on the barrette was wearing off in several places)
-Anne Marie Borlind Mascara
-Wisdom for the Sole minibook
-A coupon for Plentils -A Self Esteem award printed on 8 1/2"x11" paper made out to my first name dated 7/22/2012 -A flyer from "Enjoy Life-Eat Freely" products (Looks like the Plentils and the Mountain Mambo are products in this line.)   Thinking of canceling the Paypal preauthorization after my head stops itching.  Having kids in school and getting possibly used hair accessories screams LICE to me.  Most likely me being paranoid, but my head is still itchy!   ICK
Sounds kind of interesting actually....There are a few items (if mine is the same) that I will gift to my friend.

As far as the hair accessory goes...sanitize it. I love finding vintage hair clips, pins, and such at antique shops and they all get sanitized. I get your point though...(if it is) It shouldnt be used.

 
People are silly really for subscribing to just anything, don't be so hyper to accept a new subscription. I will not swipe my card for anyone new without thorough research. It's foolish.

Just now seeing the pics and reading the responses. Awkward. I'm out lol.

 
Originally Posted by MissLindaJean /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Pass! Looks a bit sketchy to me. If I want food samples, I'd go to Costco lol. Not trying to knock the foodie subs, but I want makeup/beauty only things. I'm also not interested in products being recycled/overlapped between subs. I get enough of that between BB and SS.
rofl2.gif
Costco, true lol

 
Originally Posted by lovesmakeup2012 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

People are silly really for subscribing to just anything, don't be so hyper to accept a new subscription. I will not swipe my card for anyone new without thorough research. It's foolish.
Not "silly" OR "hyper" to want to try new things......

I tend to be on the more adventurous side. This is no different to me (for $17) than trying out one new high end product and hating it. PAY PAL all the way also...no credit cards. Easy to cancel.

 
Originally Posted by hrseangel /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Not "silly" OR "hyper" to want to try new things......

I tend to be on the more adventurous side. This is no different to me (for $17) than trying out one new high end product and hating it. PAY PAL all the way also...no credit cards. Easy to cancel.
At least I can return the "HE products" that I've purchased if I don't like them. Nothing in the box looks good, imo. Then you all come back crying about a new subscription you despise.  I'll stick w/ the subscriptions I already have. Enjoy!

 

Latest posts

Back
Top