Drugstore Eyeliner

[blueangel1023]

I'd go with Prestige. Their waterproof liners stay on all day for me. Also love their liquid liners, it's a felt tip applicator so if you don't have steady hands they're pretty much fool proof! Jordana liquid liners would be my 2nd choice. Hehe, I'm partial towards liquid liners as u can see. If you like MAC fluidlines, Jane's Be Pure mineral gel eyeliners are just as good & it comes with a mini liner brush!

 

[kuuipo415]

I use the maybelline lineworks waterproof liquid eyeliner. best eyeliner so far! I can never use pencils b/c they always endu up under my eyes! this one has a felt pointy tip so its perfect for precise application!

 

[reesesilverstar]

Revlon Colorstay...

I wanna try the Rimmel ones, but they're always sold out - which is a sign imo...

 

[originalskin]

Another vote for Revlon Colorstay liners. They go on smoothly, are highly pigmented and have good staying power. You have to smudge them out pretty quickly if you want a softer line, if you wait too long they seem to set in place, but that is what makes them last so long, and that works for me.

 

[bCreative]

I like CoverGirl's mechanical eyeliner

 

[malibuphoenix]

Thank u so much Envymi for suggesting Prestige's Waterproof Eyeliner. I love it! Unfortunantly, the Walgreens in my town that sell Prestige are discontinuing it but...all Prestige products were on Clearance. Score! I also bought Prestige's regular black-brown pencil eyeliner. It is HORRIBLE! Goes on very harsh.

 

[lalalalila]

Styli-Style and Prestige

 

[Dalylah]

Wet N Wild Gel liners (not liquid), NYX or Rimmel

 

[riotgrrrl]

Revlon ColorStay, Loreal HIP cream liner, NYC eyeliner..

 

[Jinx]

Wet and Wild Cream eye liner; nice color and consistency and stays put on my oily eyelids.

Almay liquid liner (felt tip); easy to apply, stays put and not hard to remove (can use plain water to remove it).

 

[laurie_lu]

Colorstay pencil liner. I've repurchased this many times.

 

[xdm]

I vote 5 for Rimmel!

 

[tara1012]

I've used Loreal Le Kohl eyeliner since high school. I'm a redhead with blue eyes, so I've always worn brown eyeliner. Cafe is the perfect shade of brown - not too dark, not too coppery. I just recently bought some Urban Decay 24/7 ones though. Kinda excited to try those out.

 

[misskitten]

barry m do a really good one, it goes on really nicely with no dragging

oh and urban decay do really good eyeliners too, i think they sell them in larger boots stores

 

[ezadeza]

You should try the L'oreal hip chrome eyeliner pencil.Its so good,that its hard to come off. Its like the Urban Decay 24/7 pencils

 

[Amy Sue]

I agree on Revlon Colorstay. One of my favorite drugstore brands.

 

[Jackie Li]

I just got physician formulaone. It comes with three color in one package, because it is on sale at cvs. The color is very creamy and I love it. The only problem is when I try to buy blue color , I have to buy two more with it

 

[KeepOnSingin]

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus has been, is, and will always be my favorite eyeliner.

 

[Dalylah]

I love the Jordana eyeliner pens. They are so cheap and never make my eyes itch like some of the others.

 

[mc808913]

Prestige is one of the best drugstore eyeliners! It doesn't smudge, applies on smoothly and it lasts on the eyes all day and night! you cant go wrong