Right now, I am really liking Maybelline Moisture Extreme in Pink Bloom -- the color is very similar to my natural lip color but just a little more pink, so adds a bit of color without looking too light or too dark! Plus, the built-in lip balm keeps my lips from drying out like they do with regular lipsticks.
For gloss, I like Mod Cosmetics gloss in Sizzle because it's the only peach drugstore-priced gloss I've found with enough pigment to actually show up on my lips!