Gel eyeliner which one?

[fsumom456]

which gel eyeliner do you all prefer?

bobby brown

Mac

Loreal Hip

And which brush?

Thanks

Pam

 

[Bjooti]

I like MAC Fluidline, along with either their thin eyeliner brush, or an angled brush.

 

[PhantomGoddess]

HIP is a cremeliner, not a gel. Different formulation. This is the only one I've used, and I like it.

 

[oneewiishx0]

I use loreal hip I have never used Mac but would like to.

but HIP stays on my waterline very well.

 

[Aprill]

I Love HIP, even though it is a cream liner

 

[conny]

My favourites are MAC. I found that BB dried very quickly in the jar.

I also like Mad Minerals. HIP are not available here in UK... Fave brush is MAC 209!

 

[Shelley]

I have only tried one gel eyeliner, MAC Fluidline and I like it. I've heard positive reviews about the HIP liners and want to try them.

I use Lise Watier (Canadian brand) angled eyeliner brush.

 

[vesna]

I use MAC Fluidline, it's really great. Usually apply it with a MAC 266 angle brush.

 

[Manda]

I've used the HIP cream liners and the MAC fluidlines and I have to vote for the MAC. It costs a little more, but it is worth it because of how little is needed to go a long way, it is easy to apply and the color is great. I apply mine with a Smashbox bent eyeliner brush

 

[Trisha.]

I have the L'Oreal HIP Cream Eyeliner & I use an eyeliner brush from Avon.

 

[Retro-Violet]

i use mac, clinique, and bobbi brown.

normally i use a slant liner brush, but sometimes if i want a very thin line i'll use a flat liner brush.

 

[SimplyElegant]

I like fluidlines and use a liquid liner brush.

 

[Aquilah]

I've only used MAC gel liners, but I've heard the other two brands are good. I generally use a mini eyeliner brush (rounded) by Posh/UpStage.

 

[speedy]

I prefer Mac over BB, and I use the BB gel e/l brush to apply. Stila's, gel e/l is really nice too.

 

[usersassychick0]

i have not tried it yet, but cliniques version has seen amazing reviews on another site, i believe out of the 40 or so ppl who have tried it... 95% would repurchase.

And lots of ppl have compared it to macs fluidline and prefer cliniques... I can't wait to buy it.

 

[speedy]

I like Mac, and I use the BB e/l brush.

 

[usersassychick0]

hmmm i believe theres an exact thread already

 

[mghb]

I love Bobbi Brown's gel liners. I use a BE's angled eyeliner brush to apply it.

 

[Leza1121]

Originally Posted by fsumom456 /img/forum/go_quote.gif which gel eyeliner do you all prefer?bobby brown

Mac

Loreal Hip

And which brush?

Thanks

Pam

Hi,
I love BB's Espresso Ink, MAC's Black Track and Dipdown, and L'Oreal's Plum. Flat angle and flat edge brushes are my favorites when using gel liners.

 

[fawp]

I'm also a big fan of Loreal HIP Creme Liner. I like it better than fluidline; in my opinion, it has a truer color and stays in place a lot longer. I use NYX small, angled liner brush but any thin, angled brush would work well.