Gel, Pencil, or Liquid Eyeliner?

[justdragmedown]

i use gel everywhere. Sometimes I use pencil on my water line if in in a rush but to make it stay blacktrack with carbon over it

 

[lovers86]

i like liquid eyeliners.(ysl) i can put it easily on my upper lid

 

[Leza1121]

Hi,

I prefer pencil or gel. No liquid liner for me.

 

[jessiej78]

I have never tried gel liners, but would like to. I will NOT use pencil because this tugs at the skin and contributes to eyelid wrinkles. I love my liquid liner!!!

 

[YoursEvermore]

I use all three, depending on the look or color I want.

Pencil: L'Oreal Perfect Pencil Automatic Liner -- stay on me all day long and only smudge if you really rub your eye.

Liquid: Cover Girl Line Exact -- stays all day and I love the pen structure of it.

Cream/gel: Clinique's Brush-on Cream liner -- stays put for me and once you get the hang of the application, they're very nice.

 

[StrangerNMist]

The only thing that I've been using lately is MAC Fluidline. The look of the liner is quite different depending on how I use it, and I like the fact that I can smudge it if I want to.

As for pencils, I haven't used one in quite a while.

 

[pinksugar]

I usually prefer liquid for the top lid and pencil for my bottom waterline. I still havent found that perfect liner, either liquid or pencil that stays all day and doesnt smudge or fade

 

[mxgirl2007]

i love gel liner...i use both the bobbi brown long-wear liner and the loreal hip gel liner...i also use the benefit bad gal pencil liner...its great on the bottom lashline

 

[puncturedskirt]

CG LineExact (Just bought it a week ago and i love it)

 

[AngelaGM]

I like gel eyeliners as well.

 

[waterlily777]

call me stupid. but whoever owns Ppowerpoint eye liner by mac....

how can i sharpen that pencil??

 

[S. Lisa Smith]

Automatic pencil for me, both top and bottom. I've been usting a dark brown rather than black.

 

[magosienne]

i prefer pencil, though i wouldn't put any if i was out of UDPP, i mostly use sephora or bourjois pencil eyeliners, so their staying power could be best. sometimes (when i go for black), i'll go for pencil and liquid above the pencil, just to help myself make sure the line is how i want it to be.

Originally Posted by waterlily777 /img/forum/go_quote.gif call me stupid. but whoever owns Ppowerpoint eye liner by mac....
how can i sharpen that pencil??

i don't have a powerpoint, but i would use a blade, like a knife or a cutter.

 

[islandmama]

im sorry what is a waterline?

ive never tried gel liners, but i like pencil ones that are waterproof like Revlon. they work for me

 

[Kiraboshi]

I use liquid on my top lid, and pencil on half of my bottom lid. Usually I just use brown for everyday use, but I'll switch to black when I want it to be more dramatic.

 

[grapestain]

Originally Posted by KristieTX /img/forum/go_quote.gif MAC Fluidlines and L'Oreal Cream liners are my favorites.

Same here!

 

[spldbrt]

I very recently discovered MAC fluidline gel and I LOVE it!! It is so easy to work with, and it has staying power you wouldn't believe. The other night I fell asleep on the couch and sweetie put a blanket on me and left me there...I woke up in the morning expecting to see a black smudgy mess but it had not moved! It looked the same as when I put it on 24 hrs before. I'd never found an eyeliner that didn't smear, but this one certainly doesn't

 

[Serendipity]

I'm not sure what you all mean by 'waterline' either.

I used to use liquid as it was the only kind I could get to stay put but then I discovered Lancome kohl which I use daily now, it's so much quicker!

 

[lovelylotus]

I typically use pencil liners, I haven't gotten the look down yet with the liquid stuff.

 

[destinyjames7]

mac fluidline..