I just tried them because they were on sale at Ulta. The neutrogena line always works well with my sensitive skin and eyes. I actually bought the petal shade and put it both on my lids and a little bit under and around my eyes, as well as the inside corners. I can get away with this because I have fair skin and its very sheer...darker skin tones may want a different shade. The cooling sensation feels great and the shade and luminescence hide dark circles without the gunky makeup look.
I have one of these-- it really does give you a cooling sensation! I put it on my eyes if I wake up and they're puffy. It actually helps take the puffiness away. I've never used it under my eyes, only as a shadow on my lids. It's not one of those things I use everyday, but it's nice now and then, especially when my eyes feel really tired!