Worst/Best eyeshadows!!

Im starting this thread because I am seeking quality eyeshadows. I will start by saying the worst eyeshadow I've tried is maybelline. The color doesnt stay on my lids. The best so far is mac.

HATE Cinema Secrets e/s....LOVE MAC e/s, except for Honey Lust!

Why dont you like honey lust?? I like it.

In my opinion, LORAC and Stila have the best eyeshadows. They are super finelly milled and have a lot of pigmentation. Then in second place comes MAC. smashbox and Milani. Just my opinion though.

I like MAC e/s's a lot. I've haven't tried anything else except drugstore brands. I have a Smashbox trio, but I don't really like it (it came with a set). I think I used it once experimentally and don't remember how I liked the e/s itself. I hate Maybelline. Cover Girl is okay. Surprisingly the one Wet n Wild e/s that I have is super-pigmented.

Originally Posted by hunniebk17 /img/forum/go_quote.gif I will start by saying the worst eyeshadow I've tried is maybelline. The color doesnt stay on my lids. agree!!!

Worst: maybelline, or covergirl

Best: NXY, Milani, Stila

Haven't really ran into a worst eyeshadow yet.. but I really like Il-Makiage!

Worst: EL

Best: None

worst: all of the drug store ive tried except millani,im not fond of smashbox,avon

best:mac,stila,milani, shu

Worst: Maybelline, some CARGO shadows, NARS

Best: Lancome, Milani, Some Rimmel ones

Best: Stila, MAC, Dior

I had one Wet & Wild e/s (black) in HS and it was actually a nice, smooth texture.

Worst: Cover Girl (bad texture, doesn't go on smoothly or stay in place), Maybelline (not horrible, but not great).

best : MAC

worst : some over the counter products

Worst: Covergirl, Lancome

Best: Stila, Urban Decay, MAC, Lorac, Hard Candy, NYX

like MAC though dont have a massive collection. in cheaper brands i like some of etude

tried VOV isnt all tht bad but needs a lot of work ...

Best = MAC, Stila, Chanel, NYX, Ulta, Shu

Worst = None (as of yet)

Best: MAC, Stila

Worst: CoverGirl, Mary Kay (but to be fair, I've only tried their testers. Their full sized eye shadows might be better quality...at least I'd hope so).

Best: I cant say enough good stuff about Urban Decay eyeshadows

Worst: Drugstore brands

I don't know the best but the worst would have to be Covergirl.

Best without a doubt, MAC and Makeup Store.

Worst is Maybelline, and L'oreal...

Best : Dior,Stila,Clinique,Bobbibrown

Worst :Maybelline,Revlon,Covergirl