Jump to content

Welcome to the new and improved MakeupTalk! Please see our announcement here!



Mac vs smashbox quality

  • Please log in to reply
12 replies to this topic

#1 colormeup


Posted 05 February 2007 - 04:13 AM

I picked up some mac eye shadow the other day for the first time. Is it just me, or is it made cheaper? The box is standard glossy paper, with the plastic flip container containing the eyeshadow. Smashbox however used a thicker and textured paper box. The shadow container is plastic but had a different texture almost a rubbery grip to it, and clicks shut when it the lid is screwed on. Not to mention the shadow has a textured pattern on the top. While I realize this may not be an indicator of product quality, it seems to me MAC is cutting corners. So, being new to makeup, which one is the more quality product?

#2 KristieTX


Posted 05 February 2007 - 04:22 AM

Did you buy the MAC shadow at the counter or on ebay?
Happily married to the love of my life since October 15th, 2010. :)

#3 colormeup


Posted 05 February 2007 - 04:29 AM

At the counter.

#4 StereoXGirl


Posted 05 February 2007 - 04:33 AM

I think MAC eyeshadows are great, regardless of their packaging... :)

#5 Manda


Posted 05 February 2007 - 05:00 AM

I like both, Smashbox uses a satin black finish with their packaging. To me, they are kind of the same in quality, although I do have a lot more Smashbox mu than MAC.
Follow me on Twitter @markgirlManda

#6 KristieTX


Posted 05 February 2007 - 07:32 AM

Sorry colormeup, I'm tired. I completely read your description wrong. LOL I thought you were saying that the MAC eyeshadow had a textured top on the eyeshadow itself. I was going to ask you if you were sure if it was real. I'm losing my mind. LMAO
Happily married to the love of my life since October 15th, 2010. :)

#7 FeverDream


Posted 05 February 2007 - 07:42 AM

I must admit that my experience with MAC makeup is extremely limited, but I have a number of eyeshadows and lipsticks/glosses from smashbox that I love. Everything has a great texture and pigmentation, and I think the black finish on the eyeshadows is very classy. It's easier for me to get smashbox as well, so I'm fine sticking with that.
"We're women, we never say what we want. But we reserve the right to be pissed off if we don't get it."
-Sliding Doors

#8 Leza1121


Posted 05 February 2007 - 08:00 AM

Hi, I buy pro palette e/s pans from MAC. I'd say for the last couple of years their packaging of them has been this way. As long as Carbon e/s keeps its intensity, I'm just fine with the packaging. You're right about Smashbox. Their e/s, cream e/l and brow set comes in a rubber type case.
You must be the change you want to see in the world. - Mahatma Ghandi

#9 ms_sunlight


Posted 06 February 2007 - 06:37 AM

I adore the Smashbox packaging, it's incredibly functional. The rubberised containers are easy to grip for opening / closing, and the screw tops make sure that they close completely airtight. Not so important for powders perhaps, but essential for moister products -- by the way, I'd seriously recommend their Transparencies cream blush, so easy to wear and so blendable.
Ms. Sunlight // Elena: If in doubt, wear more blush!

#10 deejoy


Posted 06 February 2007 - 10:02 AM

Smashbox hands down is better quality to me.

#11 makeupfreak72


Posted 06 February 2007 - 10:17 AM

the quality is pretty equal to mac imo, even though i sold all my smashbox e/s a while back (and didnt regret it later) so i guess i prefer mac still, but i DO love the black rubbery texture of the cases!!! just like nars it gives the product a more sophisticated higher quality to it in a way!!! MAC still rules!!!:rockwoot:
17 lbs. lost and 5 lbs. to go!!
starting weight: 152 lbs.
goal weight: 130 lbs.

#12 Sanah12


Posted 06 February 2007 - 01:51 PM

I never used smashbox before, but i will let you know when i do. I m going to NY in a few days and buy it. Are there original smashbox stores in NY???

#13 blonde65


Posted 06 February 2007 - 02:50 PM

I love them both but I think MAC is better as it is less expensive and have a far wider range of colours. Go to Sephora, they should sell the whole line there. Enjoy your trip.

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users