- Joined
- Feb 22, 2006
- Messages
- 22,700
- Reaction score
- 1
I've tallied the votes and have put together the results. The top 3 picks of each category have been found!
Now, as a disclaimer, a lot of voters weren't specific while others were. So, while one voter might have answered their best mascara was "Lancome Hypnose," another voter might've only answered, "Lancome."
Also, a lot of brands/products tied with others, and so I didn't list all of the brands which tied in most cases (which will be very visible in most categories).
That all being said... Let's get the results!!!
Best "Prepping" Products
Concealer
1) Benefit Boi-ing, Revlon ColorStay & M.A.C. Studio Stick (tied) - 2 votes each
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Foundation Primer
1) Smashbox Photo Finish & Monistat Anti-Chafing Gel (tied) - 6 votes each
2) M.A.C. Prep+Prime Skin - 3 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Eyeshadow Primer
1) Urban Decay Primer Potion - 20 votes
2) Too Faced Shadow Insurance - 3 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Eyelash Primer
1) Shiseido The Makeup Mascara Base - 5 votes
2) Lancome & Maybelline XXL (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Brow Product
1) Benefit Brow Zings - 8 votes
2) M.A.C. Brow Finisher & NYC Browser Set (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Best Traditional Makeup
Liquid Foundation
1) Revlon ColorStay with SoftFlex - 10 votes
2) M.A.C. Stuid Fix Fluid - 3 votes
3) Diorskin Forever Extreme Wear Flawless, Prescriptives, L'Oreal True Match & M.A.C. Satinfinish (tied) - 2 votes each
Tinted Moisturizer
1) Laura Mercier - 3 votes
2) Revlon ColorStay Active, Clinique & Foundation/Moisturizer Mix (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Face (Setting) Powder
1) Bare Escentuals Mineral Veil - 5 votes
2) M.A.C. Mineralize Skinfinish Natural - 4 votes
3) Revlon ColorStay - 3 votes
Blush
1) M.A.C. - 13 votes
2) NARS - 6 votes
3) Shu Uemura - 3 votes
Bronzer
1) NARS (Laguna) - 3 votes
2) Physicians Formula Baked Bronzer, Tarte & Estee Lauder (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Variuos brands all received 1 vote each
Luminizer/Highlighter
1) M.A.C. Mineralize Skinfinish - 9 votes
2) LORAC & M.A.C. Strobe Cream (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Multi-Purpose Item
1) M.A.C. Mineralize Skinfinish - 7 votes
2) M.A.C. Pigments - 6 votes
3) NARS Multiples - 4 votes
Best Mineral Products
Mineral Foundation
1) Silk Naturals - 3 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Mineral Finishing Powder
1) Silk Naturals - 4 votes
2) Bare Escentuals Mineral Veil - 3 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Mineral Blush
1) Everyday Minerals - 4 votes
2) Bare Escentuals & Silk Naturals (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Mineral Bronzer
1) Silk Naturals - 3 votes
2) Everyday Minerals - 2 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Mineral Eyeshadow
1) Taylor Made Minerals & Fyrinnae (tied) - 4 votes each
2) Elegant Minerals, The She Space & Bare Escentuals (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Mineral Eyeliner
1) Jane Be Pure Mineral Gel Liners - 3 votes
2) Silk Naturals & Jane Iredale (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Best Eye Products
Pressed Eyeshadow
1) M.A.C. - 17 votes
2) Urban Decay - 3 votes
3) L'Oreal HIP, Stila & Make Up For Ever (tied) - 2 votes each
Loose Eyeshadow
1) M.A.C. Pigments - 18 votes
2) Barry M Dazzle Dust - 2 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Cream Eyeshadow
1) M.A.C. Paints/Paint Pots - 9 votes
2) NARS, Benefit Creaseless Cream & Diorshow Eye (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Lengthening Mascara
1) L'Oreal Telescopic - 5 votes
2) Maybelline Great Lash, Maybelline Define-A-Lash, Cover Girl Lash Exact & L'Oreal Beauty Tubes Double Extend (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Volumizing Mascara
1) Diorshow - 5 votes
2) L'Oreal HIP & L'Oreal Voluminous (tied) - 4 votes each
3) Revlon 3D Extreme - 3 votes
Gel/Cream Eyeliner
1) M.A.C. Fluidline - 19 votes
2) L'Oreal HIP & Jane Be Pure Gel Liners (tied) - 3 votes each
3) Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Liner - 1 vote
Pencil Eyeliner
1) Revlon ColorStay - 5 votes
2) Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil - 4 votes
3) M.A.C. Technakohl - 3 votes
Liquid Eyeliner
1) Maybelline - 3 votes
2) Annabelle, NYX & WnW Megaliner (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Best Lip Products
Lipstick
1) M.A.C. - 22 votes
2) Revlon - 3 votes
3) Bobbi Brown, NYX, Chanel Allure & L'Oreal (tied) - 2 votes each
Lip Stain
1) NARS - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Lipgloss
1) M.A.C. Lipglass - 11 votes
2) NYX - 6 votes
3) NARS & Lancome Juicy Tubes (tied) - 3 votes each
Lip Balm
1) Burt's Bees - 6 votes
2) M.A.C. Tendertones - 4 votes
3) Nivea - 3 votes
Lip Plumper
1) M.A.C. Plushglass, Lipfusion & DuWop Lip Venom (tied) - 3 votes each
2) Sally Hansen Lip Inflation - 2 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Lipliner
1) M.A.C. Creamliner - 7 votes
2) NYX - 6 votes
3) Rimmel - 3 votes
Best Skin Care Products
Facial Cleanser
1) Neutrorgna Fresh Foaming & Philosophy Purity Made Simple (tie) - 3 votes each
2) Garnier Nutritioniste - 2 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Facial Moisturizer
1) Philosophy Hope in a Jar - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Facial Toner
1) Clinique 3-Step
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Face Mask
1) Queen Helene Mint Julep Mask - 3 votes
2) St. Ives Apricot Scrub - 2 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Face Scrub/At-Home Dermabrasion
1) Philosophy Microdelivery Peel - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Acne Treatment
1) Retin-A & Clearasil (tied) - 2 votes each
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
SPF/Sunscreen
1) Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch - 5 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Makeup Remover
1) Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Best Bath & Body Products
Body Wash
1) Dove - 8 votes
2) Oil of Olay & Philosophy (tied) - 4 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Bar Soap
1) Dove - 9 votes
2) Neutrogena & Lever 2000 (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Body Scrub
1) St. Ives & Mad City Sue Whipped Sugar Body Scrub (tied) - 2 votes each
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Body Lotion
1) Nivea - 4 votes
2) Victoria's Secret & Eucerin (tied) - 3 votes each
3) Palmer's Cocoa Butter - 2 votes
Body Butter/Oil
1) The Body ShopBody Butter - 3 votes
2) Bio-OIl/Cocoa Butter Mix & Victoria's Secret (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Body Spray
1) Bath & Body Works Body Splash - 7 votes
2) Victoria's Secret Body Splash - 4 votes
3) The Body Shop Body Spray - 2 votes
Perfume
1) Philosophy Amazing Grace - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Self-Tanner
1) Jergen's Natural Glow - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Best Nail Products
Nail Polish Brand
1) OPI - 11 votes
2) Revlon & China Glaze (tied) - 2 votes each
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Top Coat/Base Coat
1) Seche Vite - 4 votes
2) Out The Door - 3 votes
3) Orly Bonder, OPI Natural Nail & Creative Nail Design Sticky (tied) - 2 votes each
Nail Treatment
1) OPI Nail Envy - 4 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Best Hair Care Products
Shampoo
1) L'Oreal Vive Pro & Nexxus (tied) - 2 votes each
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Conditioner
1) Pantene, Nexxus & L'Oreal Vive Pro (tied) - 2 votes each
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Leave-In Conditioner
1) Aussie Miracle Hair Insurance - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Straightening Balm
1) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Frizz Control
1) Biosilk Silk Therapy & John Frieda (tied) - 2 votes each
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Volumizer
1) Garnier Fructis - 2 votes
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Heat Protectant
1) TreSemme Heat Defense & Nexxus Heat Protex (tied) - 2 votes each
2) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Hair Color
1) L'Oreal Feria - 3 votes
2) Wella - 2 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Flat Iron
1) CHI - 4 votes
2) GHD - 3 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each
Curling Iron
1) Conair - 3 votes
2) Hot Tools - 2 votes
3) Various brands all received 1 vote each