Can someone recommend a pencil eyeliner I can use for the water line / tight lining ?

[Summer]

I am looking for a liner I can use for the waterline / tightlining. Im looking for a pencil and hoping for something I can either get at MAC or a low end brand that I can find at a place like CVS. 

Thanks in advance!

 

[makeupbyomar]

I use MAC's Smolder for that purpose, and the results look amazing.