I've never tried Sugarpill before either, but here's my list of want to trys.
Top 5 Favorite Sugarpill Products:
Tiara Loose Eyeshadow
Lumi Loose Eyeshadow
Absinthe Loose Eyeshadow
Magpi Loose Eyeshadow
Starling Loose Eyeshadow
I am a fan of Makeup Talk and Sugarpill on Facebook.