I just bought Nude last week and so far I like it. I used to have Forever, and imo it does give better coverage. Nude is very natural but does give more glow and dewey look. The only difference I can see is that Forever has a higher SPF and it's waterproof. I like the coverage & waterproof factor on Forever when I'm going out to parties and special occasions since it last all day for me, but Nude has 100% mineral pigments and more hydrating (I found the texture a little less thicker than Forever) and since I like the more "natural" look I went with the Nude. It's better for every day wear since it's similar to having a tinted moisturizer. As someone mentioned before it all depends what you're looking for. Since you mentioned staying power and coverage, I think Forever would be better for you. However if you're looking for great coverage, I'd recommend MUFE HD foundation.