It's funny cos just yesterday I was watching a youtube vid of a man who is a make up artist and he did some contouring on his face and I thought it looked great. I'm not sure how I feel about guys wearing make up, but to each his own! I think you looked good with it, it wasn't wicked out there, it was subtle but enough to say it did change your look in a good way. I agree with Bonnie, try and practice with the upper water line. I think I would say try different things and see what works for you.