Jason Natural Cosmetics Tea Tree Gel is very soothing. It's a therapeutic moisturizer enriched with tea tree oil, aloe vera, witch hazel, arnica, and echinacea. It has natural antiseptic properties; provides quick, refreshing relief from skin flare-ups, insect bites, shaving nicks, and bumps and bruises.
Another thing you might try is shaving with hair conditioner and then applying this afterwards. That's what I do and it's nice and smooth.