My Urban Decay vs NYX experiment

[PiggyDog]

Can you tell which is the $20 Urban Decay Liner and which is the $5 NYX jumbo pencil?

Looking in the mirror after having them on for 14 hours I can't tell any difference in the wear.  So which eye is which???

 

[TeresaDouglas]

I'm very curious to find out which is which! It does look like they have a similar wear time, which is good to know in terms of saving money. I really like the look of the NYX pencils in makeup tutorials.

 

[internetchick]

Hard to tell because the resolution is so low, but I would guess UD on the left and NYX on the right. Did you set either one with shadow? I found NYX Black Bean to be a poor performer.

 

[PiggyDog]

Hard to tell because the resolution is so low, but I would guess UD on the left and NYX on the right. Did you set either one with shadow? I found NYX Black Bean to be a poor performer.

No I do not put powder of any sort in my water line...