Ooooh, what a gorgeous look Laura!
Do you like to play w/colors on your eyes? If so, I think something like this would be gorgeous....
pale celery green on lid
cream to highlight browbone and inner eye
medium brown in crease
darker brown in outer "V"
black (or brown) eyeliner on top lashline, along bottom 1/3 of lashline, smudged
curled lashes + mascara
Buuuuuttt, if that's not your cup of tea, what about something like this?
medium shimmery brown on lid (like MAC Satin Taupe)
cream to highlight browbone and inner eye
black eyeliner on top lashline, bottom 1/3 of lashline and smudged, inner rims
curled lashes + mascara
Hope this helps ya some, Laura!
They're two of my fave looks, esp. the latter.