i tired both proactiv and murad.
murad has worked better for me than proative ( i guess cause if i take a break from murad, i wont' break out while proctive i have to use it religiously).
i really like murad, especially the pomergranete moisturizer for oily skin, it absorbs really fast, provides SPF15 and also, the pomergranete (the fruit with most antioxidents) provides the antiodident that speeds up ur cells, stimulating collagen.