I thought the old logic was a shade lighter. Then there are the tinted concealers that use the opposite color on the color wheel to cancel out a flaw. Green to get rid of red, yellow to get rid of dark circles. I've found the tinted ones look weird on my skin. It looks like someone took a yellow crayon to my under eye. I use a concealer that's a shade lighter than my foundation because this was a recommendation from an MA at a salon. I'm almost out of concelaer though, so I ws kiking around the idea of matching it to my foundation.