Sigh, indeed.
/emoticons/
[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> That's really frustrating. If Olive is too pink for you, maybe you need the green corrector? It's something I would check out if ever you decide to re-try in an effort to find that ideal match. Also, in that case, I would write back to the forum/Karen and ask for advice. I imagine they/she has heard of similar concerns. Right off the bat, your comment on 'porcelain' suggests to me that the mix is too light. I know I was guilty of wearing a foundation that was to light on me for a while; I was familiar with that 'porcelain' effect. If you're simply referring to the
pink doll effect, I understand, though.
/emoticons/
[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> (I'm a bit curious also about the Warm Gold colour for you, though it does sound more like you do need the green corrector 'refill' bag from your description. My match also was 'not right' until I found the ideal mix, but it did turn out I needed a bit of the green and a bit of the gold to mix with ebony; yours could possibly be more of a compound colour too.)
It was good to read your play-by-play of the experience; I imagine it will guide anyone who helps you improve the match. But -- even if you're leaning to Ocicat, do hold on to the mixes you created. They can come in handy for making other things match, or in case you do try the green corrector in the future.
With Ocicat (which do you use, btw?), can you actually layer it a bit more to get better coverage? Using a primer or a finishing powder might help. Otherwise applying a corrector/concealer in the areas that are most in need of coverage can reduce the need for overall coverage enough that you can be happy with a foundation that otherwise would be too lightweight. If that works, it would be great! I'm always impressed with the really natural, but perfected look that some women can achieve beautifully. I hope you find a good combination!
I'm always interested in hearing what people have to say about different powder foundations when they're had a chance to try several of them. Had Alima not caused you to break out I would have suggested mixing the Olive 0 and Olive 1 to get your match. I had a more complicated idea too: if Meow has a good colour match but not enough coverage, might getting a shade that is a lot darker than you need but in the right 'shade category' and mixing it with the Silk Naturals Medium Coverage Ivory to get to the right depth of colour work? I hope you find a really good solution!!