When Makeup Goes Wrong

[pinksugar]

I think my favourite look is hayden's 'after'. She looks gorgeous.

Some of the afters weren't that great IMO, like Mary-Kate for example...

 

[cheller]

a lot of the "good" i thought still looked kinda gross. like olsen, knightley, & richie. olsen looked sickly, knightley should have gone a little lighter on the liner, & richie should have more color to her face. like lips or cheeks.

 

[xoxmonicaxox]

I like alot of the BAD ones haha

 

[xtiffanyx]

I love the shade of e/s Nicole Scherzinger is wearing in her "bad" look. I guess I like 'lady of the night' looks

?

 

[alka1]

Originally Posted by MissManda /img/forum/go_quote.gif I agree that the article was a bit biased. Apparently you only look good with a nude natural lip gloss, basic neutral eyeshadow, and barely there foundation. Forget having fun with it tastefully, another attempt to make everyone look the same! I don't think the article is saying that everyone should look the same. I think it's meant to show that natural makeup tends to enhance and bring out our unique facial features.

 

[AngelaGM]

I think that they looked beautiful "Good" or "Bad".

 

[speedy]

Originally Posted by pinksugar /img/forum/go_quote.gif I think my favourite look is hayden's 'after'. She looks gorgeous.
Some of the afters weren't that great IMO, like Mary-Kate for example...

I agree, I think Mary Kate's after is horrible, she looks dead.

 

[Karren]

Well all of my photos would fall in the Bad Karren catagory.. I don't do neutrals very well.. Lol. I do like some of the "Bad" makeup photos better than the "Good" ones.. Especially I think the Bad Christina A looks better than the Good Christina A.. The Good one looks washed out and blahhhh.. In my humble opinion

 

[McRubel]

It seemed like all of the celebs in the "after" photos were tanner. Are they hating on us fair girls?

 

[Adrienne]

Alot of these weren't that bad, i agree. I guess it just depends on what you call "bad" I actually thought some of these were out there but okay.

 

[Panda816]

I went back and looked again and noticed that hairstyles played a part in it too..even though it was about make-up, Naomi's hair was definitely better in the second pic and to me that was the biggest difference. Could also be the light where the pic was shot!

 

[Stylish Daisy]

you actually can see how Fergie's nose is over covered in the first picture!

 

[Sarah84]

Originally Posted by CellyCell /img/forum/go_quote.gif The only ones who looked good in both before/after are Nicole R & Nicole S.Everyone else do look better in more neutral looks... all the makeup overpowers their features.

I wish Cristina kept her "Back to Basic" look now... she's doing this whole Lady Gaga aka Lady Caca look and it doesn't suit her at all.

I totally agree.
I love Christina's lip colour in her 'good' picture, anyone got any recommendations for something very simular?

 

[hopeless novice]

This is when makeup really goes wrong.